The fun of an Iain Banks novel is largely in its plot which makes it hard to review this book without giving away spoilers. I read none of the literature which came with the galley kindly sent to me by Little Brown so that I could ride the twists and turns of the narrative with genuine surprise. Perhaps then read this paragraph as one long SPOILER ALERT. (I am however only going to give the basic premise below so with that in mind read on or not as you wish).
...
Whew, ok, if you're still with me and you don't know who Iain Banks is that means you're probably living in North America because most of the rest of the world has been on the Iain Banks express for a couple of decades now. Let me briefly catch you up. Banks is Scottish and lives in Fife well outside the orbit of the London literary set which largely inoculates him from their solipsistic bad habits and allows him free reign to give us stories and characters without a lot of lit-crit baggage. In other words he produces page turners. Banks writes contemporary fiction often with a political or conspiratorial thrust under his own name, but he also writes science fiction novels under the name of Iain M. Banks.
...
To slightly confuse matters his new book Transition is available as an Iain Banks novel (the edition I got) and as an Iain M Banks book. I think the reason Banks isn't just calling it straight sci-fi is because his science fiction novels are mostly space operas set in a high tech universe whereas Transition takes place on contemporary Earth - actually, as we'll see, Earths. I've been a fan of Banks since I read the first two of his Culture books in high school and I slightly prefer the sci-fi stories to the contemporary ones which made it all the more exciting to find myself in the middle of an Iain Banks novel (no M.) which was a cross dimensional romp across alternate universes.
...
...
Banks builds his story polyphonically showing us several different points of view, including those of an assassin, a torturer, an agent controller and a mysterious patient in a hospital bed. The book takes place in 2009 and was evidently written last autumn which gives it a breathless quality I very much enjoyed. Transition in fact is vintage Banks: fast, exciting, funny and every enjoyable. There's a bit more sex than usual and this being Banks it's sex with an interdimensional twist. Banks juggles the characters well and keeps the story ticking along nicely. In terms of pace, diversity of voice and Big Ideas Transition reminded me of his underrated Feersum Endjinn which I think is the best of his non Culture science fiction novels.
...
A few minor quibbles: Banks does not explain the hard science of the jumps between worlds (just as he never explains the hard science of the hyperdrives in his Culture novels) and this will either be a relief or an irritation depending how far up the geekdom Y axis you happen to be. Banks's politics too can sometimes be a little intrusive and although in Transition he mostly keeps his views on the back burner his swipes at libertarianism would be a bit more sophisticated after a look at, say, Robert Nozick. And I'll admit that I groaned as soon one particular character said that "Mrs Thatcher was a Saint" and that "Scotland was a miserable land full of midges and Scots," - from that moment on I knew the poor fellow was as doomed as a random red shirt on a new planet. But these are minor issues. Transition is a taut, assured novel from a writer at the top of his game; for my money it is Banks's best book in a decade and is far and away the most original thriller of the year.
49 comments:
The Culture series seems to be catching on a bit here finally, but you're right--Banks can't seem to get a real toehold in the U.S. The one I've been told to read a few times recently--maybe here in part--is The Bridge, which doesn't seem to be currently all that available.
I haven't read any Iain M. Banks novels, but Espedair Street is one of my all time favourite books.
The usual moral superiority prize for the person who can identify the blog title quotation.
Seana
I liked the Bridge and not just because I like that particular bridge. One of my top 10 favourite bridges in fact. (now there's a bad idea for a blog post).
You're right though, he is gaining ground but he should be massive.
John
I'd rec Consider Phlebas - if you like that one you'll probably like the other M Banks books. Espedair's the one about the music biz right? I liked it too.
I'm looking forward to this one!
That quote is too easy, why dont you give us a hard one?
Doug
I very much enjoyed it. It aint just for fanboys either.
Ian
Really? Well I notice you forgot to actually guess.
I thought your thriller "Fifty Grand" was very original!
thanks mum
Nice review Adrian. I too have read Transition and I liked it very much. I'd put it up there with Garbadale, so not exactly his best in a decade, but pretty good.
Your blog title is a line of dialogue from a man pointing a gun at another man in a restaurant/diner in LA.
I'm not your mum! I dont even know you. Just a fan of DIWMB and 50G. And am looking forward to this too.
Ok Anon, I believe you.
Getting several newbies to this site today it looks like. Glad to see the Banks fans are keeping track of him. Believe me, if you're a fan, you'll love this book.
You may yet make a science-fiction nerd of me.
==============
Detectives Beyond Borders
"Because Murder Is More Fun Away From Home"
http://detectivesbeyondborders.blogspot.com/
I thought the quote was just something I'd say on a bad day at work, except that it would be 'do' not 'don't'. Other than that, I have no idea, even with the clue. So it's not too easy for everyone, Ian. Though I suspect you were just being sportsmanlike in not guessing.
I am not even going to waste time taking odds on whether or not there will be a top ten bridges post. Two clues: List. Bridges.
Peter
I prefer geek.
McFetridge prefers Iain Banks and I think your tastes are closer to his than mine so why not give him a try without the M?
Seana
I'd definitely include the Rialto which in fact is where the climactic scene of Transition takes place...oops spoiler alert.
In fact now that I think about Banks probably has a thing about bridges too.
I'm afraid I may have trouble remembering whether I'm supposed to look for Iain Banks with or without the M, but I hope I'll be able to come up with something good. I can always ask McFetridge if I'm in doubt.
I don't know that I'd be able to come up with ten favorite bridges, but I can name two: the Clifton suspension bridge in Bristol, and a very cool bridge in Rotterdam.
=================
Detectives Beyond Borders
"Because Murder Is More Fun Away From Home"
http://detectivesbeyondborders.blogspot.com/
Well, I think Iain and Iain M. would be shelved in different sections of a store or library, so that would sort itself out.
I like places with multiple bridges like London Paris and Dublin, and I particularly like pedestrian bridges. There are a lot of foot bridges on the Santa Cruz campus, although now that I think about it, most of them don't seem to cross water.
Peter,
you could try The Crow Road,
which begins with the famous line
"It was the day my grandmother exploded."
In Banks case I prefer the non-science fiction output. I'm not alone in that - Jo Walton has commented that of all the authors who write both sf and mainstream, he's the only case in which she prefers the non-sf.
This idea was concocted to explain some aspects of the collapse of the quantum wave form and it's one that I've never really bought into,
So what's your alternative explanation? Me and the Physics Nobel Prize Committee are waiting with bated breath.
You know already I'm a Banks fan, so I'm really chuffed you liked this. You've also cleared up why it's listed on Amazon as by two publishers. Well, one publisher, two different imprints, but you know what I mean.
And I'll gladly lap up a non-space opera sf novel. I found his last Culture book a bit waffly and self-indulgent when it came to the techie bits.
Peter
Well I say M, John says no M, Marco says no M, so just stick to the fiction dept and you'll be fine.
Seana
Did you ever take a punt down the "backs" in Cambridge? Bridge heaven if you ask me. Even though I went to the other place.
Marco
Well I dont think it's an elegant or likely solution. I have a bit of an "out there" idea. Do you know about non locality and the Einstein Podolsky Rosen paradox? Apparently it deomnstrates the nonsense of quantum mechanics because it allows faster than light travel, but unfortunately for Einstein its actually been proven in the lab again and again. What I think is happening is that quantum waves are travelling TWO directions along the arrow of time, forwads and backwards, thus non locality and the laws of physics are not violated and you dont need the many worlds theory to explain the collapse of the quantum wave form.
Mike
I hope I didnt provide too many spoilers but I do think you'll like this one. I enjoyed it, even though it wasnt an M. We both liked the last Culture book more than the Algebraist though didnt we?
How could I have forgotten Dublin’s Droichead na Leathphingine, or Ha'penny Bridge , much photographed and deservedly so? (I’ll try to remember to post a photo of it when I get home tonight.)
==============
Detectives Beyond Borders
"Because Murder Is More Fun Away From Home"
http://detectivesbeyondborders.blogspot.com/
Thanks for the Banks recommendations, all. I'll have to do more than just scrawl Banks on my shopping list, though. That would be no help in the matter of M or no M.
I always read the summaries on the book jackets so now worries regarding potential spoilers in your review, Adrian. And yeah, Matter was definitely a better read than The Algebraist.
Peter
Funnnily I walked over that bridge just last week.
A nice bridge that always chilled me was the Bridge of Sighs over New College Lane in Oxford. I had to ride under it to go the Examination Schools and it always gave me a cold feeling of death.
Mike
Makes me want to do a list. Top 5 Banks Culture novels:
1. Excession
2. Consider Phlebas
3. Look To Windward
4. The Player of Games
5. Inversions
Seana
Just for you.
Top 5 Bridges I've visited
1. The Golden Gate Bridge, SF
2. Forth Rail, Scotland
3. Sydney Harbour, Australia
4. Bridge of Sighs, Venice
5. The GWB, NY (purely for sentimental reasons because aesthetically its not great)
I prefer the low-tech Culture novels, so...
1 - Inversions
2 - Player of Games
3 - Use of Weapons
4 - Consider Phlebas
5 - Matter
Favourite Banks novel of all...
The Bridge, followed very closely by Espedair Street.
I didn't realize you'd made it to Dublin. You did a lot of travelling for such a short trip.
Don't forget this bridge. And Edinburgh has all sorts of odd bridges and tunnels.
==============
Detectives Beyond Borders
"Because Murder Is More Fun Away From Home"
http://detectivesbeyondborders.blogspot.com/
Yes, Espedair Street is the music biz. And includes the line, "Born in a council house in Paisley, a rock hard introduction to life." My next door neighbour was born in a council house in Paisley and he's the one who gave me the book.
Toronto is a funny city in that it really has no bridges. I grew up in Montreal riding my bike over the Jacques Cartier bridge, though the Victoria is the one with the real history. That's the bridge built by Irish immigrants and Mohawks from Kannewake. When the hurling stick met the lacrosse stick on the frozen river hockey was born...
Seana
I'm shocked that you think I was kidding. ;0
The quote "I'm in a transitional period and I dont want to kill you." comes in this scene at 3:50.
Mike
Inversions was pretty good. You dont like the ones about the ships then it seems. I have to say I enjoy seeing them buzz about.
Peter
Yeah I was in Dublin for about 6 daylight hours. Not much of a stay really but I did manage to hit a few of my usual targets.
John
I forgot that. Of course I was born in Council house in Carrick which is much more alliterative and in the context of the Troubles in 1970's Belfast perhaps slightly more interesting.
Last April I was flying from London to Denver via Montreal and was pretty shocked to see the river completely frozen but for one small channel for shipping. I couldnt hack this, I remember thinking.
Ian
Yup you are absolutely right. Remember back then when we all thought Tarantino was the next Scorsese? Boy were we wrong.
What I think is happening is that quantum waves are travelling TWO directions along the arrow of time
A bit "out there" is about right
Top 5 Banks Culture novels:
1. Excession
So you like Big Dumb Objects. Have you read Roadside Picnic by the Strugatsky brothers?
John
It has the Bloor Street Viaduct - or Ondaatje shouldn't be trusted in anything?
Remember back then when we all thought Tarantino was the next Scorsese? Boy were we wrong.
My one claim to fame as a serious movie-watcher was not being fooled by Tarantino. Of course, I'm older than you lot and was already past my impressionable stage. And I'd already read all the original source material (Elmore Leonard novels).
I did gain a lot of respect for Tarantino, though, when he admitted he doesn't make movies for grown-ups. If only his fanboys would realize this, too.
And yes, Marco, there's the Bloor Viaduct, but how much of a bridge can it be with the subway crossing it?
And yes, Adrian, sometimes the mighty St. Lawrence actually freezes (how crazy cold is that?!?). Still, a trip to Montreal in the summer is fantastic. You could visit the Victoria Bridge and see the Black Rock memorial for the Irish laboureres killed in the construction (it's actually a big black rock they dug out of the bottom of the river).
Thanks for those top five, Adrian.
I do like that Ha'Penny Bridge. For some reason the bridge that came to mind just now was the Royal Gorge Bridge over the Arkansas River in Colorado. For some reason, when I was a kid this was the place we used to take visitors. Yes, spectacular, but some of them were afraid of heights, and this is the world's highest suspension bridge...
I never saw Pulp Fiction. Wasn't totally convinced by friends telling me how funny it was.
marco
yeah I loved that one with the ships and the object and the little ships.
no I havent read that, do you think it would be might sort of thing?
Seana
Yup I've been there. Its definitely something to take people to who visit you in Colorado, that and that big ravine in northern New Mexico.
John
Well you were right. Its all the more disappointing because I really liked films 1 and 2 and thought 3 was moving him in a direction of a new maturity. Grindhouse killed that idea forever and this new one sounds disastrous.
do you think it would be might sort of thing?
No ;)
It was the basis for Tarkovsky's Stalker. Aliens have briefly visited the earth and left, or maybe have just briefly touched its surface in six different points (given earth's rotation) coming from somewhere near Deneb. The 6 "visitation zones" are dangerous - strange phenomena happen, time passes differently, gravity, magnetism and light may start to behave in odd ways and even if you escape freak accidents prolonged exposure has mutagenic effects, though it is not clear what causes the mutations. They have therefore been quarantined. People at the border with the zones may leave normal lives, but when they emigrate they seem to cause unexplained disasters.
Only scientists and "stalkers" enter the zones, the former to study, the latter to loot and sell to black markets the artifacts they find there (in thirty years barely a 1/1000th of the zones has been explored). While the true purpose of the artifacts and the science on which they're based resist any attempt at analysis or reverse engineering, after trial and error and lots of casualties mankind has learned to use some of them for effects that range from the trivial to the miraculous.
Some scientists believe the zones are a test, a prelude to contact: understanding the artifacts humanity will make a giant technological leap and be able to signal the aliens that they're ready for contact on equal footing.
Another scientist believes the zones and the artifacts are merely leftovers from a "roadside picnic" along some road in the cosmos. The truth is that aliens probably didn't even notice the humans, humans don't have a frame of reference to understand the aliens' motivations and therefore anthropomorphize them, and are just like squirrels and other forest animals trying to make sense with their limited understanding of the mess left by a group of young people after a picnic - apple cores, candy wrappers, remains of a campfire, bottles, a torn newspaper, a handkerchief, oil spilt on the grass, etc.
Marco
I dont know, that sounds really interesting. I may have to check that one out. Do you know that JG Ballard was offered the novelisation of Alien? He turned it down and then really regretted it when he saw the film.
Here, as promised, is the Ha'Penny Bridge.
==============
Detectives Beyond Borders
"Because Murder Is More Fun Away From Home"
http://www.detectivesbeyondborders.blogspot.com
Post a Comment