I reviewed James Ellroy's Blood's A Rover for today's Australian newspaper. The first few paragraphs are below and you can read the full review here. Spoiler Alert: I liked the book. Also in today's Australian there's an interview with the Napoleon of Irish fiction, John Banville, talking about genre writing.The Heavyweight in the Red Corner
Boxing aficionado, James Ellroy, is a little like the Joe Frazier of American letters. While Thomas Pynchon, Don DeLillo and Cormac McCarthy get spoken of as contenders for the title of America’s Greatest Novelist, Ellroy often gets dismissed as a mere crime writer. His amour propre, his past as a teenage neo-Nazi, and the fact that he writes about that most gauche of places, Los Angeles, has never endeared him to the literary establishment.
...
Blood’s A Rover, however, may just well change their opinion. It is the completion of Ellroy’s near two thousand page American Underworld trilogy that began with the evocative American Tabloid and continued with the extraordinary The Cold Six Thousand. American Tabloid is a technically impressive and often brilliant novel structured around the Cuban Revolution and the Kennedy assassination, written in a clipped ultra telegraphic prose style that reinvents American crime fiction in a way no writer has attempted to do since the 1920's. Harsh, single word, verb-less sentences pile on top of one another like the dripping tap of a water torturer, producing a hypnotic, trance-like effect which repels as many readers as it seduces. But where American Tabloid is a book teetering on the edge of a cliff, The Cold Six Thousand jumps completely into the abyss with an even sparer haiku-like prose style and a complex narrative of conspiracies, invasions and cover-ups starting with JFK’s murder and ending with the assassinations of Bobby Kennedy and Martin Luther King.
...
Blood’s A Rover breathlessly continues the story in the days following King’s death in Memphis. The central characters in the book are the ones we got to know (and in most cases dislike) in The Cold Six Thousand - the conspirators who planned the hits on both Kennedy brothers and MLK. If this sounds a bit crazy, well, it is. In Ellroy’s America (and one assumes he does not actually believe this) Dr. King was shot by Hoover’s FBI working with the mafia, Cuban exiles and the CIA. King’s murder incites rioting in America’s black ghettoes and Richard Nixon rides the conservative backlash to get elected with a little help from the mob, Dominican drug dealers, an ex FBI macher called Dwight Holly and a murderous ex Las Vegas cop, Wayne Tedrow Jr. who ended book two of the trilogy by helping beat his father to death with a golf club.
....
To complete the Freudian trio of central protagonists in Blood’s A Rover we are introduced to the new character of Donald Crutchfield, a neophyte private investigator, voyeur and pervert. Ellroy has described himself as the ‘Tolstoy of crime fiction’ and Crutch is transparently Ellroy’s Pierre Bezukhov - a mostly sympathetic avatar of the novelist himself, who gets his kicks (as Ellroy once did) by breaking into women’s homes to sniff their underwear.
...
We follow these diverse sociopaths on a wild ride through the politics, controversy and insanity of America in the seventies with Ellroy gleefully libelling the conveniently deceased Nixon, Hoover, LBJ and Howard Hughes who were all in on the whole Kennedy thing. And yes I know this is a novel and not actual history but I still find it a little disturbing that Ellroy absolves such real life individuals as Sirhan Sirhan, Lee Harvey Oswald and James Earl Ray, all of whom are mere patsies in the wider conspiracy. Then again, though, maybe that is the point, as in Quentin Tarantino’s Inglourious Basterds, Ellroy’s world is not quite our world: this is an alternative 1970's, a slightly darker America where intelligence agencies, the military industrial complex and very rich men are the sinister puppet masters. (One shudders to think what Ellroy could do with 9/11 as subject matter.) ...
...
...
(You can read the rest of this review over at The Australian)
64 comments:
Well done, though I haven't gotten over to the rest of the review yet.
Just read the Paris Review interview with him, which was great fun, though doesn't probably cover much new ground. In a weird way, I was reminded of the Karamazov father in Brothers K.--the canny buffoonery. But he cops to it, and that's a lot.
I don't know if Americans know enough American history to distinguish that this is an alternate version. We used to stop learning somewhere around Reconstruction and start all over again. I don't know what they teach about JFK these days. I think the movies end up being the definitive version, which is scary.
In the Paris Review, I think he's saying he's at work on something else. Wonder what it is. I don't think it would be 9/11, as he seems to have found his material in a certain American time period.
He also said that Europe loves him, much more than the U.S. They have probably accepted the dark side of us much more than we have.
Seana
Needless to say the best bit of the review is the bit I held back which is over in the Aussie. I do think Ellroy can be criticised for this female leads who are not always that satisfactory or interesting.
The Paris Review doesnt have an active link to that interview does it? I tried to link to one they did with Patrick Fermor and the thing never worked.
At his Philadelphia reading, Ellroy called Holly and I think Crutchfield as well his two favorite characters.
==============
Detectives Beyond Borders
"Because Murder Is More Fun Away From Home"
http://detectivesbeyondborders.blogspot.com/
Peter
That does not surprise me, though if he was really going for shock value he should have said that his favourite character was your fellow Quebecois, Pete Bondurant.
I thought he might have said Wayne Jr., but then why would the creator of such a weird human menagierie like a character simply for that character's occasional flashes of decency?
==============
Detectives Beyond Borders
"Because Murder Is More Fun Away From Home"
http://detectivesbeyondborders.blogspot.com/
Needless to say, I'm going to read the whole review, but I just noticed this was up on a short break at work.
There's this link to the Paris Review but it's really more of a tease than anything else. Maybe they'll add more when it's not the current issue.
What female leads?
Ellroy's comments about Chandler and Hammett say more about Ellroy than about Chandler or Hammett. It's interesting that Ellroy, who seems driven to put his own dark impulses into his books, praises Hammett for writing "the kind of guy that he was afraid he was.'
I sympathize somewhat with his complaint that the press writes about his sensational side while ignoring his reading. In Philadelphia, Ellroy laid great stress on the role libraries played in his life, said his father dropped him off at the Los Angeles public library when he was 3 years old "and that high." And he'd say things like "I got in trouble with women and reading, reading, reading, reading, booze, reading, reading, reading, reading."
He said the subject of his next book was so big that he could not name it.
==============
Detectives Beyond Borders
"Because Murder Is More Fun Away From Home"
http://detectivesbeyondborders.blogspot.com/
Ian
I liked the way you tied your review into the other books in the trilogy. I suppose these books need to be read as one big novel. I havent read any Ellroy, should I start with American Tabloid?
Also "the Napoleon of Irish letters" not sure if that's a good thing or a bad thing.
He said the subject of his next book was so big that he could not name it.
oh crap its 9/11 then isnt it?
He said the subject of his next book was so big that he could not name it.
oh crap its 9/11 then isnt it?
If it is, then Ellroy is an old shitehawk, because 9/11 is certainly not too big to be named -- unless it's about 9/11, but a story behind 9/11 that is so big he could not name it.
==============
Detectives Beyond Borders
"Because Murder Is More Fun Away From Home"
http://detectivesbeyondborders.blogspot.com/
Seana
Yeah it looks like they dont want to give away their content gratis. I suppose they still make their money from sales of the hard copy. Those Paris Review Interviews books are great though. I have 1 and 2.
Peter
They say you should never meet your heroes and I probably shouldnt meet Ellroy. He cant be that cool and interesting in real life.
Ian
At least for the paperback of Fifty Grand John Banville and I will be at the same house Picador in the US, so of course its a good thing.
Anon
I really hope not. Rover ends roughly at the time of Watergate and I'm curious what could be bigger than 9/11 between Watergate and now. Maybe he'll go back and do WW2?
Peter
9/11 with Cheney as the lead baddie? Could be gold. No other US novelist would have the cojones.
Yes, for some reason, interviews are one of my absolutely favorite forms, both written and spoken--when they're well done, of course. I should probably get those Paris Review books to see the ones I've missed, which would be most of them. I also like most of the ones I've read in The Believer, which are also collected, and Tin House does good ones as well.
I don't know how to say this without possibly offending any MFA types who might be lurking here, because it's not my intent, but one of the refreshing things about Ellroy is that his path was not and MFA path, and he is so not an MFA guy. Can you imagine having him in your writing critique group? Actually, it would be fun, come to think of it, as long as you were up to it.
I'll have to hold off on this one. I was told yesterday BLOOD'S A ROVER is mu next assignment. I look forward to it with mixed emotions, as the only other Ellroy I've read is THE COLD SIX THOUSAND, which I know you liked.
Adrian, I wouldn't bet on 9/11 with Cheney as the bad guy. Cheney's still alive, after all, and Ellroy says one reason he chooses the subjects he does is that the real-life protagonists are all dead and can't sue him. On the other hand, maybe he knows something about Cheney's heart condition that we don't ...
=================
Detectives Beyond Borders
"Because Murder Is More Fun Away From Home"
http://detectivesbeyondborders.blogspot.com/
seana said...
... I should probably get those Paris Review books to see the ones I've missed.
Sounds like a series of blog posts to me.
=================
Detectives Beyond Borders
"Because Murder Is More Fun Away From Home"
http://detectivesbeyondborders.blogspot.com/
Seana
In the Paris Review books the writers who are more interesting too are the ones who took a different path to literature. The MFA ones and the rich ones just dont have the verve of the others.
Dana
I think you might like this one better. The style isnt as radical as The Cold Six Thousand and the story is a little less shaggy too. Although I preferred Cold Six.
Peter
Yeah good point. Maybe Reagan then? I dont know I'm trying to think of something huge...
Peter
I know this is thread jumping but Chester Himes's description of the prison fire in the Ohio State Prison is amazing writing.
What I liked in the interview is that he is always amazed when people don't get his underlying moral sense when if you actually pay attention to the storylines, all the creeps come to grief through their own self-destructive doings.
I think he knows a thing or two about self-destructive tendencies, though.
Once we're speculating about Regan, 9/11 and so on, it may help to remember that Blood's a Rover completes a trilogy. Ellroy's next book may go off in some other direction. You've read more of him than I have and would probably be better able to speculate about what that direction might be.
==============
Detectives Beyond Borders
"Because Murder Is More Fun Away From Home"
http://detectivesbeyondborders.blogspot.com/
Adrian, I've only ever read Himes' Gravedigger and Coffin Ed novels, one of his stories, and bits of another novel. I don't know his description of the prison fire, though I may have read references to it.
==============
Detectives Beyond Borders
"Because Murder Is More Fun Away From Home"
http://detectivesbeyondborders.blogspot.com/
Seana
Well they dont all come to a bad end. Also a lot of good people get punished too. In that way its quite like life aint it?
Peter
I like Himes. I've read 4 or 5 of those stories. Found them all pretty enjoyable. The stuff about the prison fire was in Esquire I think.
I probably didn't give exactly the right impression of what he was saying, and certainly not as colorfully, but I don't have the Paris Review with me.
Himes had a little revival some years back, but it didn't seem to come to much.
Marco
Picasso was definitely a nut and by - several divisions - crazier than Tilda Swinton.
Seana
I have a feeling its not that cozy. And I dont think the male equivalent versions are that cozy either. Still I really like Tilda S and I think she just signed without going into all the particulars, maybe like Wes Anderson and other people I like.
Yeah, I was just kidding around. I trust your sense of things, though I do think you know way too much about celebrity lifestyles to be entirely healthy.
Oops. Anonymous would be me.
Seana
And there was me thinking Tilda was reading the blog.
Well, you never know.She might be lurking.
By the way, here is what Ellroy really said, which I got slightly wrong--okay, maybe more than slightly:
I feel that I have a responsibility to portray the spiritual, religious side of life. I hate squalor. I'm always astonished when people come up with the nutty idea that my books are nihilistic. I try to show the result of immoral actions: the karmic comeuppanc, the horrible self-destructiveness. I explicate the dire consequences of historical and individual misdeeds. What happens to you when you do not know that virtue is its own reward.
great review. i continue to wait for it, as apparently the book sold out overseas (the UK I assume as we get their editions) and has not yet shipped here. Ridiculous. the 17th is apparently when it will hit shelves.
great review. i continue to wait for it, as apparently the book sold out overseas (the UK I assume as we get their editions) and has not yet shipped here. Ridiculous. the 17th is apparently when it will hit shelves.
Cam
Thats total madness. They need to have anticipated that this book was going to be huge. Now everyone is just going to buy from Amazon. Stupid, stupid, stupid.
I know! it's not like it's Book One from Johnny First-Timer is it? The amount of mis-information I've had in tracking it has soured me on bookshops, actually. I used to work in a comic shop (big surprise) and I could tell you every bloody comic from every bloody publisher and when it was coming to THE WEEK. Readings actually said "it might be in a box out the back but not sure." I then found out that the publishers in the UK ran out. fucking hopeless. The whole situation is crazy. I didn't Amazin it coz I thought it'd be quicker and the UK edition is, as usual, handsomer. regretting that.
Amazon it, I should say.
Cameron, where are you? I mean, which country? We've had copies for several weeks here --autographed copies, actually. They're selling okay, but they haven't hit the Indie lists. But even the Indie lists are dominated by Lost Symbol and the new Galbaldon right now.
It's one of the biggest falls on record for fiction, but still the usual suspects dominate. We were speculating that a lot of the fiction is going to do a lot better when it comes out in paper next fall. If we all can just hang in there.
Picador sounds like a good place for 50G, by the way, Adrian.
Seana, I'm in Melbourne, a few suburbs away from Adrian, actually. Our books are almost always the UK editions,hence they are always late, and ROVER was due Oct 1. The frustrating part has been why nobody could tell me what was happening or when it was actually coming "October sometime" was the standard response (which I personally found appaling for a business trying to move units). Luckily, a cute staffer at an indie shop has saved the day actually calling me (twice)-*gasp* customer service!- and letting me know very honestly what the score was. Gotta be honest though - most of my stuff comes from amazon. Charlie Huston, Ken Bruen, Joe Lansdale and our man Adrian (amongst others) can be difficult to find.
oh, and local crime guy Peter Temple outsold Dan Brown at Readings last week. Not much of a victory since you can get your Brown at the supermarket, but not bad.
Well, I'd remember that extra touch of indie service, Cameron, but despite working for one forever, I understand the lure of Amazon and other online sources, especially for those far from publishing centers.
I've noticed that our distributors have a lot of fall titles listed as Oct. 1st titles when actually they aren't coming out till mid or late month. Don't know what that means, but it makes it hard to explain to customers why certain titles haven't arrived yet.
Ellroy isn't coming to Melbourne, is he? I mean, nothing would surprise me.
oh, I am remembering it! I promised I'd buy it from them since they were the only ones to actually give half a shit and the phone call was really sweet. And no, the man himself isn't coming, least not that I'm aware. Think he made it out here for The Black Dahlia many years ago, but not even positive about that.
Also, though we move a lot of Dan Brown books, he's basically a loss leader, as our top ten is heavily discounted. Frankly, it seems like we should be discounting lesser known authors and selling big names at full price, but we're caught in the same dilemma that the rest of the book industry is in, and apparently can't change it.
Still, it's nice that Peter Temple outsold Dan Brown somewhere. We have a few big fans of his work here. Sad to say, I haven't read him yet. Hope to, though.
and regarding distributors, I seriously can't believe they can't work it out. It can't be that hard to give an accurate release date. The comics industry does it with no trouble at all and they release in a week what the book publishers release in several months. It's stupid and if I was a book retailer I'd be pretty annoyed about it. Having said that, the comics distribution system is monopolised, so that may have something to do with it, but bugger it, I know when something's coming.
interestingly, again with the comics analogy, Marvel boosted the prices of many high-selling titles in order to keep lower-selling ones viable.
Temple is very good, but I do have to say that the newie isn't really doing it for me (halfway through). It's a bit like an Aussie episode of The Wire but no where near as interesting as that sounds.
I don't know what goes on in Australia, but at least here, this situation seems pretty unusual. Usually, there is a street date for big books, and you're not supposed to sell it before that date, though the local chain seems to break that rule pretty frequently. But I noticed several titles where we had one street date and the distributors had another earlier one, and basically, it seems like some miscommunication has happened. Data entry error maybe.But that still doesn't explain why they can't give you a rough idea in Australia.
Well, I've got plenty of older Temple titles to get through first, so the new one is not a big worry for me. I have a copy of The Broken Shore here somewhere, which comes highly recommended.
oh, and local crime guy Peter Temple outsold Dan Brown at Readings last week. Not much of a victory since you can get your Brown at the supermarket, but not bad.
Local South African Peter Temple is one of the world's best, though he may be a bit too much of a Clive James fan for Adrian's taste.
=================
Detectives Beyond Borders
"Because Murder Is More Fun Away From Home"
http://detectivesbeyondborders.blogspot.com/
Cam, Seana
Indeed it is true. I just went for a walk over to Acland Street and popped into my local Readings Bookshop. Not only do they not have Blood's A Rover (!!) but they dont have any Ellroy at all. They have lots of RJ Ellroy whoever that is and plenty of the new PD James but no James Ellroy. You have to think to yourself whats the point of even reviewing it if no one can buy it.
Peter
Peter Temple is great though isn't he? Sure he's on Clive James's side over the whole Wehrmacht helicopter thing, but he writes a hell of a novel. (Better than Clive).
They have lots of RJ Ellroy whoever that is
That's RJ EllORy, third from the end, reading clockwise from lower left. I can't understand the Ellroy vanishing act, though,
=================
Detectives Beyond Borders
"Because Murder Is More Fun Away From Home"
http://detectivesbeyondborders.blogspot.com/
Well, I assume after reading your review people will just order it on Amazon. Which in this case, it seems they should.
Peter, Seana
Normally I wouldnt advocate buying a book from Amazon over an independent book shop but when they have ZERO of the author's books that's a different story.
Thanks for the tip about Ellory, Peter, hadnt come across him/her before.
Adrian, I haven't read Ellory, but good things have been said about him, particularly about A Quiet Belief in Angels.
=================
Detectives Beyond Borders
"Because Murder Is More Fun Away From Home"
http://detectivesbeyondborders.blogspot.com/
Peter - is that you with Christa Faust in that pic? she's awesome. MONEY SHOT should have won the edgar for best paperback original, I think. And, yeah, this Ellory dude is everywhere...Ellroy; not so much. Weird.
Peter - is that you with Christa Faust in that pic? she's awesome. MONEY SHOT should have won the edgar for best paperback original, I think. And, yeah, this Ellory dude is everywhere...Ellroy; not so much. Weird.
Cameron, that is indeed me with Christa Faust. Money Shot was a fine book, and I think the opening to her novel Hoodtown may be even better. She's a pretty damned good writer, a magnetic presence, a hard worker and an interesting character.
Ellory's novel that I mentioned above has won readers' awards as well as critical praise, so I think he probably bears investigation. And yes, I have seen his books side by side with James Ellroy's.
=================
Detectives Beyond Borders
"Because Murder Is More Fun Away From Home"
http://detectivesbeyondborders.blogspot.com/
With a working knowledge of things like COINTELPRO and CIA & co dealings with the Mob and drug traffickers you will be able to indentify that Ellroy is building his fiction on a foundation of solid facts.
Anon
Yeah, except that Lee Harvey Oswald, James Earl Ray and Sirhan Sirhan are far from the innocent patsies which they are portrayed in the trilogy.
I think the potrayals of Hughes, JFK, Bobby and especially Hoover are pretty damn close though. And the important thing is that its all very plausible. More plausible in some ways than the truth.
I did meet James Ellroy and the maxim was not true.
It was when Cold Six Thousand was out and our shop ran a signing event. We organised a showing of LA Confidential but he said he hated the film so we went for dinner instead. The talk was mostly about David Peace and boxing.
The highlight was when he told us that the real 'Pete Bondurant' was still alive, just, and still with 'Barb' living a quiet life.
I did hear that his next book was going to be about Warren Harding.
Rob
Sorry I had to moderate your comment but I've been getting so much spam lately that I've had to moderate all comments more than 28 days old which seems to thwart the bastards.
The maxim I take it is "never meet your heroes"?
I liked the boxing stuff in Ellroy's memoir. I wonder what he'd make of the sorry state of the current heavyweight divisions.
Post a Comment