Saturday, March 6, 2010

Case Closed - A Comet Wiped Out The Dinosaurs

When I was a kid no one knew what had happened to the dinosaurs. There were, of course, lots of theories including: ice ages, vulcanism, asteroids and even as my old geography teacher used to claim - Noah's flood. In the 1980's geologist Walter Alvarez (working with his father Nobel Prize winning physicist Luis) discovered evidence (in the form of iridium scattered all over the globe at the K-T boundary) that a massive comet had struck the earth 65 million years ago wiping out half the species on the planet and almost all of the dinosaurs. Alvarez's theory was confirmed when an impact crater was found at Chicxulub in the Yucatan Peninsula. The crater was the correct age and had been made by a comet or asteroid 15 miles long which had struck the Earth with an impact a billion times more powerful than the A bombs dropped on Hiroshima and Nagasaki combined.
...
I first read about this theory way back in 1985 in Carl Sagan's book Comet (when I was still in high school and thus able to bring it to the attention of my geography teacher) but it has taken until now for it to be confirmed with the publication of a paper at the 41st Lunar and Planetary Science Conference in Houston. A distinguished panel of experts examined all the available evidence and competing theories and concluded that the Chicxulub hypothesis was the correct one.
...
I've been to Chicxulub, indeed, I set part of a novel there. There's not much to see except jungle: weathering has eliminated all trace of the impact crater, but it's still a strange and interesting place because it's from there that every one us owes our existence. If the rogue comet had arrived in our solar system at a slightly different angle or perhaps as little as 10 minutes earlier, the internet would have been invented by intelligent dinosaurs and we mammals would still be hiding up the trees.

18 comments:

Brian O'Rourke said...

Nice linkage. I wonder how we mammals survived the impact, when the dinosaurs, et al., didn't.

Off topic, but what's up with the naked people outside the Sydney Opera?

adrian mckinty said...

Brian

And crocodilians survived too. Of course any creature that can effectively live at the bottom of a river and only has to eat once a year will probably survive the next comet too.

I always seem to miss the naked people...

seana said...

I'll bet your high school geography teacher just loved you.

Regular readers of this blog will know that you do not always miss the naked people. Does Parson's Pleasure ring any bells?

adrian mckinty said...

Seana

Yes, Parson's Pleasure, I forgot about that, hopefully that place is no more...

My geography teacher also believed that glacial landforms were caused by the Biblical flood and that fossils were put on Earth "to test our faith" - he probably works for Sarah Palin now as some kind of science advisor.

Peter Rozovsky said...

That geography teacher was put on Earth to test your faith or at least your patience.
================
Detectives Beyond Borders
"Because Murder Is More Fun Away From Home"
http://detectivesbeyondborders.blogspot.com/

dpougher said...

Of course, you could argue that many corporations, even countries, are run by intelligent dinosaurs. Gordon Brown has always reminded me of an angry triceratops.
And as to why mammals survived, well most of them didn't. At least 50 per cent of species were wiped out but smaller dinosaurs survived and probably evolved into birds and the grittiest of the mammals held on. Makes you wonder what we lost, though.

adrian mckinty said...

Peter

He leant me a book called Evolution: The Fossils Say No! which was a classic of its kind. i.e. utterly mad.

adrian mckinty said...

David

Hopefully not in your newsroom.

I know of at least 3 s-f stories where the dinosaurs survived and actually became intelligent. West of Eden by Harry Harrison was probably the most interesting.

Declan Burke said...

As far as I know - I'm no geography teacher - the impact of the comet would have thrown up massive amounts of debris and dust, which would have effectively cut down on how much sun could get through the atmosphere, making it a very difficult for large cold-blood animals (dinosaurs, and any others not living in rivers, lakes, seas, etc.) to survive, given that they're dependent on exterior sources for their body heat. The small warmblooded mammals, on the other hand, had an internal heating system going on. Plus they wouldn't have needed to eat as much, which was a good job, because a darkened planet wouldn't be marvellous at growing stuff.

Erm, would that be part of it?

Cheers, Dec

Anonymous said...

Yes, that's way down in Mexico - Meyer I had gone to find a missing girl - I has done a favor for her father a few years ago, and he had remembers. Her name was Bix - and somehow she can gotten mixed up with a crowd a hippies out for jaunt on the wildside that somehow had turned into a trip to the seamy side of hell. It seems one of the older kids started to turn them on. At first it was just pot - but then the crazy little games got wilder and little red and blue bills were introduced.

The ones where you don't know what your trip is going to be and when and if you will ever come back. And it seems that sweet little Bix had a side to her that her Boston bred family and country day school friends never imagined. Oh yes...we jolly through the days and romp the lovely ladies and sip the iced Boodles - but every now and then...usually just about the crack of dawn...the monster hiding in the bottom of closet gets loose and shows his fangs and all we can do is slink back in the big round bed and shiver and sweat in hopes that, at least this one more time, that cold clean sun will break again over the chill Atlantic.

I came awake with a start...a tiny scuffling sound on the deck. The hairs stood up on my arms and reached - ever so quitely - for the mean little 32 Colt I keep under the bed.

More later - Bright Wind from Mountain

Peter Rozovsky said...

That's because the title did nto appeal to the righr audience. Had the book been called "Evolution: F--- the Fossils," it might have held stronger appeal for contemporary youth.
==============
Detectives Beyond Borders
"Because Murder Is More Fun Away From Home"
http://www.detectivesbeyondborders.blogspot.com/

adrian mckinty said...

Dec

That makes a lot of sense. We mammals should stick together.

I think its increasingly clear too that birds are in fact the descendants of the dinosaurs that survived.

adrian mckinty said...

Bright Wind

Ahh, I see you've taken my advice about the fan fiction...

adrian mckinty said...

Peter

I wish I'd kept it. It was actually pretty funny.

Sheiler said...

Evolution: The Fossils Say No!...It's the title of a musical, coming soon to a theatre nearest you.

adrian mckinty said...

Sheiler

I'd pay to see that.

Peter Rozovsky said...

You must have enjoyed the Oscars: James Cameron loses, his ex-wife and Jeff Bridges win. OK, a Tarantino movie won an award, but you can't have everything,
==============
Detectives Beyond Borders
"Because Murder Is More Fun Away From Home"
http://www.detectivesbeyondborders.blogspot.com/

Adrian said...

peter i'll reply on the other thread...having probs logging in here for some reason...