Friday, December 23, 2011

The Irish Crime Fiction Supergroup

Guess which one is Colin Bateman
For the last year or two here on my blog I've been trying to get people interested in my books in particular and in Irish crime writing in general. It's sometimes been an uphill struggle because, compared to Nordic or English crime fiction, Irish crime writers still seem to lurk in the periphery. This is strange to me because in terms of quality and diversity Irish crime fiction is booming. I wonder if Ireland has an image problem: years of insidious and dreary cliches in what I like to call Micksploitation films have conditioned the book buying public to demand fiction that conforms to their expectations. When people think of Ireland they still think of smoky pubs, flat caps and sheep; they want their Ireland to be the Ireland of the 1950's. Working in a New York Barnes and Noble I discovered that Irish Americans are not particularly avid readers and when they do buy books it's often something ghastly thing like How The Irish Saved Civilization or The Best Irish Castles. Therefore if you want to sell books with an Irish theme in America you have to reach beyond the Irish American community but there again you are often hit by the stereotypes and imagery of what it means to be Irish. When the average American punter buys an English or Nordic mystery novel they think they're getting something that not only will entertain them but will also improve them in some way because Swedes and Englishmen seem so darn intelligent. And this I feel appeals to something deep in the American psyche - the need to better oneself.   
...
Irish fiction is intellectually on a par with any other literature in the world and I'd go further and say that Irish crime writing currently leads the world in diversity and richness. That such a small island can produce such a welter of talent is truly amazing. On his blog, Crime Always Pays, Declan Burke tirelessly promotes his fellow Micks and although I am not as well read as Declan, here are few authors that I have read in the last couple of years that I think you should be aware of...who knows it might even help with some last minute Christmas shopping. 
... 
*Declan Burke: Dec's latest novel Absolute Zero Cool may be his masterpiece. Channeling Flann O'Brien Dec has an original and utterly brilliant take on the contemporary crime novel. 
*Stuart Neville: Stuart's first novel The Twelve was a work of genius. Incredibly his follow up books have only gotten better. Don't let the beard fool you, he's just a kid really, and he's got a long promising career ahead of him. 
*Eoin McNamee: Perhaps the most intelligent and thoughtful of this generation's crop of Irish novelists. At home in literary fiction and crime fiction, Eoin's book Orchid Blue is one of my all time favourites. 
*Ken Bruen: Sir Ken of Bruen is The Man as far as I'm concerned. The Irish Elmore Leonard or possibly the Irish Michael Connolly, but, you know, funnier. He's done many wonderful books since but there's a soft spot in my heart for Her Last Call To Louis MacNeice, one of his early classics.
*Ronan Bennett: This generation's Graham Greene. As comfortable in film and television as he is in fiction. Havoc In The Third Year is one of the great novels of our time and it should have won the Booker Prize. 
*Garbhan Downey: The bard of Derry. Garv hilariously unpacks the foibles and fantasies of the denizens of Ireland's most eccentric city. My favourite? War of the Blue Noses. 
*Kevin McCarthy: Only got to one Kevin McCarthy book so far but that was the fantastic novel Peeler. Definitely one of those books that you'll read compulsively in one long sitting. 
*Colin Bateman: Cursed by a childhood in Ireland's most boring town, Bangor, Bateman rose above the tedium of tea shops and ice cream parlours to become a best selling comic novelist. His done nothing but brilliant work since but I still love Divorcing Jack from a few years back. 
*David Park: A thoughtful, intelligent, subtle novelist in the Graham Green/Brian Moore mold. More of a literary guy than a crime guy really. His masterpiece, The Truth Commissioner, is the book to read if you want to understand what happened to Northern Ireland from 1968 - 1998. 
*Tana French: I was in a bookshop in Tokyo looking for something to read on the train and in among the Japanese novels was a shelf full of Ms French. I bought, I read, I loved. Now I've read them all and they're all great. 
*Ruth Dudley Edwards: A true prose master. Her crime novels are fantastic but for me her book about the Omagh bombing takes us to another level. A must read for anyone who is interested in contemporary Ireland. 
*Brian McGilloway: You all know Brian don't you? One of the brightest lights in all of Irish literature. Intelligent and tough with a poet's heart, he's a best seller in the UK and Ireland and he's increasingly huge in America. If you don't have a BMCG book go get one, now!
*John Connolly: How do you crack America? Well, if Brian McGilloway and Stuart Neville are the Kinks and the Stones JC is the Beatles. You crack America by writing taut, original, stylish crime fiction with a supernatural bent.  
*Gene Kerrigan: I just finished Kerrigan's The Rage and I thought it was amazing. I'll definitely be reading more in the future.  
*Dec Hughes: The Wrong Kind of Blood is the first in the great Ed Loy mystery series. Hughes is street wise, smart, witty and just a little bit cocky. 
*Gerard Brennan: One of the new generation of N Irish novelists and playwrights. This year I read Brennan's hilarious, tight, brilliant novella The Point. 
*Alan Glynn: Winterland is one of my favourite books of the last five years. I haven't read Glynn's latest but I surely will. 
*Cormac Millar: Only read one CM book, The Grounds, but fortunately it was a fantastic read. Definitely adding more to my TBR pile. 
*Arlene Hunt: Also only read one Arlene Hunt novel but luckily that was also pretty damn fine. It was called The Chosen and it was one of my books of the year.
*Alex Barclay: I really enjoyed Barclay's Darkhouse, one of my favourite books of 2010.
...
Like I say, this list is not exhaustive. I'm not as well read as many people in this field, but if I've piqued your curiosity at all investigate the authors above and please check out Crime Always Pays and Detectives Beyond Borders for a more comprehensive look at Irish crime fiction.

64 comments:

Dana King said...

This kind of post always surprises me a little because I'm such a fan of Irish crime fiction. Maybe because when I was reviewing books for New Mystery Reader web site, among the first I got was John Connolly's THE BLACK ANGEL. I loved it (still think it's Connolly's masterpiece), and the editor pick up on my enthusiasm and sent me books by Declan Hughes, Declan Burke, Ken Bruen, and something called THE DEAD YARD whose author escapes me.

So, to me, Irish crime writers stand second to no nation, even though I don't get easy access to as much of their writing as I do some others. Which is why I'm always surprised when they don't get their props.

I've also been fortunate enough to interview all of the the above, and you won't find a nicer bunch of blokes.

Cary Watson said...

I think you're bang on with the Micksploitation theory. North Americans have a fixed image of Ireland that's made up of equal parts lace, leprechauns, and cute, colourful country folk permanently attached to pints of Guinness. Hardboiled Irish crime fiction probably seems a contradiction in terms to a lot of readers. They don't want their twee image of Ireland messed with. Each nationality has its cliche(s), and pop culture resists any tampering with them.

Gerard Brennan said...

Dude! Thanks so much for including me in this list. This'll go down as one of my 2011 highlights...

gb

adrian mckinty said...

uh oh, this post went live before I finished writing it. dont know how that happened.

I'm going to have to make it vanish until the 24th...

Gerard Brennan said...

Well, I'll thank you again when it comes back!

Cheers

gb

Kate said...

Adrian,
Thanks for including Irishwomen on the list.
Modern Irish poetry, especially from NI, is also amazingly varied.
Dragon Tattoo disappointed and left the impression that Swedes aren't a very self-expressive bunch, esp. compared to NI writers. Larsson didn't write very insightfully or compellingly about his country.
I'm one Heinz-57, semi-Mick American who avoids British culture because I feel inferior. Is there any truth to the stereotype that the British are smarter and more creative than Americans?

frankie said...

I think I might give one or two on your list another go. Def Ronan Bennett as he lives locally. I had a go with John Connolly and Tana French, I just felt they were a bit one dimensional and not meaty enough, but I may have been wrong then. What I don't understand is the people on your list are all really successful novelists so how are they being overlooked? Have I missed the point?

adrian mckinty said...

Kate

Its just a personal opinion but I happen to think that Irish poetry punches way above its weight. Look at the talent: Seamus Heaney, Sinead Morrisey, Paul Muldoon, Ciaran Carson, Derek Mahon, Tom Paulin, Michael Longley, Maire Mac an tsaoi, etc.

adrian mckinty said...

Frankie

A lot of them are successful in the UK but many of them can't even get published in America. Colin Bateman is a good example. Huge in Britain. Couldnt find a US publishing house. Compared to the Swedish novelists who are published everywhere.

frankie said...

Oh I see. I have no clue about outside UK. Do you think Batman's novels would travel well, like in America? I'm not sure.

Books are great christmas prezzies. My brother gave me your Bloomsday Dead for chrimbo a couple of years ago. I've also just bought a Seamus Heany book for a friend. How many poems has that man written? Loads.

Arlene said...

Aw, thank you sir, I"m very happy to be included with such fine company. Happy Christmas to you and yours. Here's to a cracking 2012.
Arlene

Frankie said...

Declan Burke tweets a link to your blogspot. The Irish Crime Fiction Supergroup is taking over the world!!

adrian mckinty said...

Dana

I remember how hard it was to get distributed in the early 2000's. Barnes and Noble reps told me that if my book (Dead I Well May Be) didnt sell in the first two weeks then they'd have to take it off the shelves because shelf space was so precious.

I guess thats why its so hard to break though.

adrian mckinty said...

Cary

It is a contradiction and its very difficult for people to hold two contradictory images in their head.

Its a real shame in terms of Ireland because the Micksploitation image of Ireland is so so boring.

adrian mckinty said...

Arlene

My pleasure. Your book was terrific.
I hope to read more of your books in 2012. You'll be happy to know that they ARE available in my local bookshop in St Kilda.

adrian mckinty said...

Frankie

What is this twitter thing I hear so much about?

Peter Rozovsky said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Peter Rozovsky said...

Oh, shit, you all are Irish? I thought you were from ICeland.
===================================
Detectives Beyond Borders
"Because Murder Is More Fun Away From Home"
http://www.detectivesbeyondborders.blogspot.com/

Paul said...

While not exactly an avid crime novel reader I've always really enjoyed Colin Bateman and John Connolly.I guess I'll have to spread my wings a little bit further.I did however see a little note on the bookshelves praising Eoin McNamee today in Waterstones.
Unfortunately it's too late to add all these to my xmas list so I'll have to spread them all during the year.
Of which, Happy Christmas to you and family.It's been a pretty interesting read during the year,funny,informative and dare I say it full of culture.
Happy Christmas to all the readers as well.

adrian mckinty said...

Peter

Well, the Icelanders like to tell you that there are all descended from Vikings. In fact the majority of Icelandic DNA is Scottish and Irish

http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2009/01/090116073205.htm

adrian mckinty said...

Paul

Bateman's always good for a laugh. And the man's work ethic is incredible. No intention at all of just putting his feet up and chilling for a bit.

Happy Christmas to you too.

Kate said...

In some circles, are crime novels regarded as somehow less literary than other forms of fiction? The artistic quality of NI crime writing is often very high; much of the prose really is poetry. I've got lots of reasons to be grateful for the genre. It deserves a wider audience.

Anonymous said...

Adrian,
Has anyone discovered where most Irish DNA comes from? (I like to think it comes from Spain, but that's just wishful thinking on my part.)

Peter Rozovsky said...

Interesting that that bears out written sources. Introductions to sagas will tell you that some of the Scandinavian settlers of Iceland had stopped off in Ireland or Scotland for a generation or two. No surprise that they’d have picked up some Celtic concubines, partners, or colleagues on the way. What it boils down to is that Arnaldur Indriðason is as much a part of the boom in Celtic crime fiction and tartan noir as Ken Bruen or Ian Rankin,
==================================
Detectives Beyond Borders
"Because Murder Is More Fun Away From Home"
http://www.detectivesbeyondborders.blogspot.com/

seana said...

I am pretty sure that all the people in the photo are actually Colin Bateman.

It's such a great list of authors and it is hugely frustrating as a bookseller that I have to say so often, you ought to check out this author, but unfortunately, you can't get the book here. I'm happy to have read quite a few of them, but at this rate, I will never run out of options. Which is a good thing.

seana said...

Here's something to get you into Twitter, Adrian. I'm watching a young guy called Alwyn Collison on Lawrence O'Donnell, who is tweeting World War II as a real time event. The link is here.

He seems pretty bright, but doubtless you could catch him out if you tried.

adrian mckinty said...

Kate

Crime fiction isn't hated among literary highbrows as much as sci-fi and romance but its still hated or at least not treated as seriously.

adrian mckinty said...

Anonymous

Stephen Oppenheimer reckons that about 80% of Irish mitchondrial DNA comes from the Basque country.

adrian mckinty said...

Peter

I'd like to see a mystery novel or even a good novel that takes place in Norse Dublin.

adrian mckinty said...

Seana

I can think of a lot of problems with live tweeting WW2. For example the vital work of Bletchley Park didnt become known until 1973. One of the most important agents, Garbo, didnt have his work acknowledged until the 80s. The stuff that made the news in other words wasnt the really important stuff that happened. Also the really important stuff happened on the Eastern front which many people are completely ignorant about.

seana said...

I don't quite know how he sets up the premise, but he does seem like he is pretty sharp. Or at least an all consumed obsessive geek.

Perhaps he is tweeting from the perspective of God.

Peter Rozovsky said...

I’m not sure I’d heard of Ronan Bennett before, but I just read about a quarter of Zugzwang over two Dogfish Head Chicory Stouts at my local bar. Thanks!
===================================
Detectives Beyond Borders
"Because Murder Is More Fun Away From Home"
http://www.detectivesbeyondborders.blogspot.com/

Peter Rozovsky said...

I can think of a lot of problems with live tweeting WW2. For example the vital work of Bletchley Park didnt become known until 1973. ...

Geez, are you old-fashioned. You probably still are under the sway of legacy media. Hell, you probably don’t even know that “friend” is a verb.
===================================
Detectives Beyond Borders
"Because Murder Is More Fun Away From Home"
http://www.detectivesbeyondborders.blogspot.com/

Peter Haxton said...

Adrian-

This is a great list and I'm looking forward to trying some new authors.

Peter R - I picked up Zugzwang last night from the library, but haven't had a chance to start it yet. So, don't give away the ending.

Kate said...

Irish tour guides love to tell you the Vikings in Ireland were just 3 and a half feet tall, bowlegged, severely arthritic, etc. It's hard to picture such people building churches or engaging in Viking activities.

The Secret of Kells is a good family movie set in Viking times. We are Norsemen is a funny T. C. Boyle short story set partly in Ireland. Belfast's Flann O'Brien probably could've written an even funnier one.

adrian mckinty said...

Seana

I'm guessing here, but I bet he thinks WW2 was won on the western front.

adrian mckinty said...

Peter

Ah, yes, I enjoyed that. Not alas over a fantastic Dogfish Head. I think Havoc is still my favourite.

adrian mckinty said...

Peter H

Good luck. there's a lot to choose from so you should be able to find something.

adrian mckinty said...

Kate

The problem is that the Norse founded all of Ireland's great cities except Belfast. The natives were the enemies of civilization still raiding cattle and fighting each other. Not a good story for a tour guide.

Peter Rozovsky said...

“The Secret of Kells” does not exactly portray the Vikings in a positive light. Those Vikings raid an Irish monastery, presumably because there were no cities to sack. It was up to the Vikings to create those cities. Good animation, thouhs, with all kinds of clever use of colors and motifs from The Book of Jells.
=======================================
Detectives Beyond Borders
"Because Murder Is More Fun Away From Home"
http://www.detectivesbeyondborders.blogspot.com/

Peter Rozovsky said...

Er, Kells, not Jells.

Peter Rozovsky said...

Peter H.: Nothing to give away yet. I haven't reached the end.

adrian mckinty said...

Peter

The Irish have very resistant to the idea that anything good could have come from foreigners, which of course is silly. Ireland is as much as mishmash of identities and cultures as anywhere else in Europe. Most of the names we think of as traditionally Irish, Fitgerald Fitzwilliam etc. are Norman, Kennedy is a Scottish name etc. Of the 15 or 16 Irish Presidents of the USA before JFK almost all of them were Protestants from Ulster. Try telling this to someone in a bar in Woodside and they'll call you a traitor or a liar. Its pathetic really.

adrian mckinty said...

Very nice article in today's Guardian about gender switching in classic fiction. You dont need Zombies or a Murder Mystery you just switch the he's and she's.

http://www.guardian.co.uk/books/2011/dec/23/classic-fiction-genderswitching

frankie said...

I don't believe in all the DNA stuff. We don't know anything for sure. Ireland has a lot of ginger people compared to say the Basque country. I say pick what you want to be and stick with that. I saw a half ginger half Chinese man the other day. I couldn't stop staring at him on the tube. Very rare sighting.

Kate said...

Adrian

I'm a chauvinist who thought the Vikings were the enemies of civilization. Like Peter R. says, that's how they seemed in Secret of Kells. But obviously they were very advanced and probably very literary, too. There's a lot I don't understand. In The Bloomsday Dead, doesn't Michael Forsythe suggest that modern Irish violence is a Norse legacy? I like Funeral Rites by Seamus Heaney but I have no clue why it ends with an image of a smiling Viking prince.

And I'll never understand the science of DNA. I thought people first came to Ireland from Scandinavia via Scotland. (I was hoping for Spain so I could have an excuse to see Galicia. Either way, there's no explanation for my brothers' "Celtic soul-'fro" hair.)

Frankie said...

Kate, you can be Spainish if you like. I would never take the DNA test as I would be inconsolable if I were to discover I wasn't Anglo Saxon. Identity is such a complex thing. Like I said earlier, its best to make it all up as you so desire.

Unknown said...

Great post. Many authors I have read and some new ones to check out. Btw, if an author isn't available in the ApUSAmazon, you can change the country settings and shop the UK Amazon.

Unknown said...

Great post. Many authors I have read and some new ones to check out. Btw, if an author isn't available in the ApUSAmazon, you can change the country settings and shop the UK Amazon.

Kate said...

Frankie

You may be right about choosing an identity. We're all mutts anyway, right?

John McFetridge said...

Tweeting WWII, wow. I don't really know anything about Twitter. I am reading the newspaper from 1970 every day and finding the unfolding of events fascinating (I had no idea the doctors in Quebec went on strike the same time the FLQ kidnapped two people) but now I feel very old-fashioned to be writing a novel with this stuff. Maybe I should just live-tweet it whatever that is (though whatever it is, I have a feeling only internet providors and a couple of huge companies make any money from it).

seana said...

John, I don't really know anything about Twitter either, but I'm not against it. It's just that my comments go long, so I don't think it's really my medium.

I didn't really expect Adrian to become a convert, but I do think it might be an interesting way for the current generation to learn a bit about that war.

Not about the Eastern Front, of course...

Adrian said...

Frankie

Stephen Oppenheimer's book The Origins of the British is a really good read. You'd be surprised where the Anglo Saxons came from.

Adrian said...

Kate

I vaguely remember that bit. I think Michael suggests that Ireland would have been better off if St Patrick hadnt come and it had stayed pagan. I dont know about that.

Adrian said...

John

Twitter is a bridge too far for me.

I'm more likely to move into that unabomber cabin in the woods than get myself a twitter feed.

Adrian said...

Seana

I still think that SC lady whose name escapes me was right about the internet.

Adrian said...

Unknown

And dont forget if you do use Amazon please give me a review...

Sheiler said...

Eileen Myles wrote up a trip she took
in 'The Importance of Being Iceland'. Not crime fiction but still a great read about Iceland's DNA. It's the title piece in a bunch of short stories and interviews. So good that I slowed my reading speed down in order to savor it.

Peter Rozovsky said...

Sheiler, Arnaldur Indriðason made Iceland’s DNA a central part of his novel Jar City, though one reader who knows her science said he flubbed the novel’s handling of double-blind tests.
===================================
Detectives Beyond Borders
"Because Murder Is More Fun Away From Home"
http://www.detectivesbeyondborders.blogspot.com/

Sheiler said...

Peter, thanks...I'll add Jar City to my book list. It's only recently that I've been re-thinking about my stance on journalism vs fiction writing. I was a journalist major for about 2 semesters when I switched schools and majors to ...something less factual. But this was an error in thinking on my part because the made-up stories can't be 'wrong', can they? I see something in a movie, or read something and note that they've got the area code wrong for, say, Gloucester MA, as Mamet did in a movie, and it's the only thing that stays with me.

I guess I've always known this, but right now it's hounding me.

Writing about anything with science is tricky that way.

Peter Rozovsky said...

Sheiler, I have spent my entire adult life in journalism, and my feelings about the profession swing wildly. Sometimes I think I have wasted my life. Other times I think my career as a hurdle I must overcome.

Sheiler said...

your career path is going through wild swings, so it's understandable. I don't quite know what's next since you can't really get around ... writing, or can you?

Kevin said...

Adrian, Thanks so much for including Peeler in your list. Signing contracts--fingers crossed--on the follow-up this week. In an effort to smash the Irish (American) stereotype, I owe you a jar or two next time you're in Dublin. Peace out, Kevin

Peter Rozovsky said...

Kevin, I'm pleased to hear the news about a follow-up to Peeler. Keep us posted.
====================================
Detectives Beyond Borders
"Because Murder Is More Fun Away From Home"
http://www.detectivesbeyondborders.blogspot.com/