![]() |
| This was the fourth image that came up on my Google Image search for Yoga |
...
Why? I'll tell you why. I've had a bad left knee for a long time now and in the last year it was diagnosed as a "pre arthritic condition" whatever that means. Basically it hurts in the morning and I can't really run on it or play soccer which is annoying, but I do swim nearly every day and most of the time the pain is completely manageable. So I'm not complaining but I am looking for non surgical solutions to the problem and I have tried many different things including acupuncture, massage and a variety of medications. Recently on the advice of several people I decided to try hot yoga. It was not a good experience.
...
First lets understand what hot yoga is. It is NOT called hot yoga because the room is full of hot chicks. Yes the room is full of hot chicks but you can't concentrate on them because the room has been heated to 120 degrees. They have the place this temperature because, I kid you not, its hot in India and that's where yoga came from. That's the logic. On this principle bananas should only be eaten in a humidor. I have no proof of this but I'm reasonably certain that our yoga instructor spent her formative years running a V-C prison camp in Laos. She was a small, energetic woman with a powerful set of lungs and she used these to good effect. She screamed at us from the beginning of the class to the end, yelling at us not to drink water as it disrupted the timing and telling us to work harder and to hold the poses longer. After five minutes I wanted to leave but I was frankly terrified of this lady. Is it likely that she would have hurled a shuriken throwing star at my neck as I was slipping out? No. Is it impossible? Again, no.
...
I quickly discovered that I was in front of one of the heaters that kept blasting hot air at me every few minutes. That plus the constant screaming and the pain of the poses and the denial of water cracked me like an egg. I would have talked. I would have told them anything. I would have signed anything. But there was nothing to sign. Just more pain and more yelling.
...
An hour and fifteen minutes went by the way time goes by at a Noam Chomsky lecture. When it was finally over we were advised to rest on the mats for a few minutes and then shower but I ran into the street instead. I felt like Dieter Dengler, or maybe like someone who more than two people reading this blog would have heard of. The yoga place I went to happens to be next door to the biggest brothel in Melbourne, possibly the biggest brothel in the Southern Hemisphere, so there were quite a few dodgy characters hanging around and a desperately panting man, pouring with sweat, in flip flops & wife beater t shirt was not that uncommon a sight. I got in the car, drank my water bottle and an old one I found under the seat and blasted the aircon.
...
The result? Well my knee did feel better for a day or two after the hot yoga experience but there's no way I can bring myself to go back. I'll take the bad knee over the demented V-C Colonel any day of the week.
...
*None of these "facts" are remotely true and to be honest I'm surprised you even thought they were.

36 comments:
Excellent article it today's Times from Eric Asimov on the whiskies of Islay:
http://www.nytimes.com/2011/12/07/dining/reviews/whisky-from-islay-scotland-spirits-of-the-times.html
By coincidence there's a long bit on Islay whiskies in The Cold Cold Ground. Coincidence or a man ahead of the curve? You be the judge.
Great story.
I know that someone I know does hot yoga, but I can't remember who.
My mom was into doing yoga way back in the 50s, and both my sisters do it now. But despite that, and the fact that pretty much the entire population of Santa Cruz does yoga and walks around with a yoga mat under their arm, I haven't really been able to get into it. My last experience of trying it I wasn't very flexible and I sure am not more flexible now.
One friend who had a chronic leg problem finally solved it by doing the Egoscue Pain Free method. I don't know if it would suit you, but it's pretty gentle, though time consuming.
My favorite yoga studio experience which I've probably told here before was when I went to some evening classes with friends once. Towards the end, people were posing themselves in complicated positions upside down on the wall, using leather straps and things. I wasn't good enough to get in those positions, but as the class was ending and we were all doing some corpse pose or something, we heard a voice coming from the shadowy back wall. "Could someone help me get out of this position?" This guy was trapped upside down in position by the leather strap around his legs.
I did not sign up for the next level.
I just remembered who it was I knew who does hot yoga, and I guess that she actually is pretty hot.
I'm not a therapist, but excessive heat can't be good for a bad knee - you are supposed to do the RICE thing right? Rest, ice, compression, elevation. But what might work for you, given your interest in physics, is "quantum jumping." Google it if you haven't seen an ad yet. All you have to do is jumble the atoms a bit and commune with your alt self in an alt universe and set things right. Then jump over to another alt and talk to the Adrian that knows all about marketing, and you'll get published in the US and I won't have to wait so long to read your books. Solves all our problems!
And...regarding the scotch article - very surprised he rated Lagavulin lowest - that has always been my favorite, and put Laphroaig at the top, which I consider very good but not great.
Ha! Fantastic. My wife did hot yoga at the same place and as she was always late getting out - and I was on duty to pick her up - I became the creepy guy often seen hanging around the world's biggest brothel. I'd imagine hot yoga is a little like living in Darwin, without the giant beers and beaches. And crocodiles.
Try Pilates. I've been doing it for six months and it's helped all sorts of bits that I didn't even know were stuffed.
My job requires standing all day lifting heavy cases; years of simple, thrice-weekly Hatha and Iyengar yoga helped alleviate my back spasms, sciatica, and even my anxiety. But one of my classmates almost broke her arm falling forward in crow position, and another woman had to be taken to the emergency room after a simple thread-the-needle posture caused her hip replacement to pop out of place. It was horrifying.
But our instructors always urged us to pace ourselves, never to push ourselves to the point of pain, to inform them of any physical issues that might require alternative postures - and always to drink plenty of water.
I never tried power yoga because its founder, a maniac named Baron Batiste, compares himself to MLK and JFK, and thinks you should do 150 sun salutations a day.
I'd chuck all other forms of exercise if I lived near a nice, warm-water beach.
Alas, the guys at my local yoga class were never exactly hot.
Bet you heard about Dieter Dengler through Werner Herzog.
Joe
Oh, right - the Rescue Dawn pilot.
120 degrees while exerting yourself with no water for over an hour? Maybe they call it hot yoga; you try that at a high school football practice and it's a felony.
Maybe a heating pad. or neoprene brace? This sounds not just extreme, but borderline dangerous.
Seana
The next level would have taught you how to escape.
I checked out the video on that pain free method. I made give it a go. I've basically tried everything else.
Dennis
My favourite the Ardbeg came in at number 2 so I'm not displeased. Amazing that that distillery almost went under a few years ago.
Islay incidentally is a paradise. I used to sail up there when I was a kid. Fantastic place.
David
It is not a great idea to put a yoga place next to a mega brothel is it? Two very different types of clientele. Although at least you know your car wont be stolen with all those shaven headed Russian dudes in leather jackets hanging around looking terrifying.
Anon
Baron Batiste is his name? He sounds like a lunatic. I was told going in that we had to follow a strict script and that no deviation was allowed from it, hence the speed and lack of water breaks etc. I wonder if thats the same megalomaniac.
Joe
Yup certainly did. The Little Dieter doc and the Christian Bale film.
Anon
Interesting guy.
Dana
We were allowed water at the beginning and the end, but we werent allowed to break the poses to drink from out water bottles as it "disrupted the flow of the class" which was total insanity in my opinion.
I ran this post past my pre-med and yoga devotee daughter. Her thoughts:
Not only have I heard of it, I've done it--only difference is, I've done bikram yoga which is developed for the heat and has a completely different approach that other forms, and a lot of non-yoga savvy yuppies go to "hot yoga" which can be very dangerous depending on how it's taught. If its taught like a normal class but with heat, that's terrible. Bikram yoga however is a different discipline of yoga and I thought it was great AND they have water breaks built in regularly and make you drink before coming and before leaving and after leaving. Not only that, the one I went to had a really good instructor who was monitoring the class closely and was not so drill-sergeant-y. It's not supposed to be super fast paced because you're getting cardio from the heat. I've heard plenty of bad stories about hot yoga, I don't think it should be allowed to be taught because so many people do it dangerously.
Untill recently I've been doing Feldenkrais classes. Its about exploring movement and easier less stressful ways to move. Its a very gentle technique. The class is made up of people who suffer chronic pain conditions. It has to be said the best thing I ever did was go to an osteopath who is brilliant. I would reccomend Ultrasound, simple stretches, swimming, omega oils. It has to be said knees are a complex joint and problematic to treat.
Dana and Miss King
Thanks for that.
I had no idea this hot yoga stuff was so controversial going in.
I may try another type of yoga again but I dont think I can go back into that environment. I think my physician misjudged my levels of stamina and stoicism.
Frankie
I just looked that up on Wikipedia. It looks very interesting and a lot less pressure it seems. thanks for that.
I've thought about trying regular yoga but have recently decided Against it. My better half and I have been doing Insanity this past month, and there is one workout that has some simple yoga in it. I hate it. That little bit of yoga has convinced me yoga is not for me.
Regular yoga or pilates should be fine, but that class sounds like masochism.
Glenna, you do not really strike me as a yoga kind of gal.
I still might turn out to be, because I am not getting any more limber as time goes on. But I must admit I am very drawn to a (for real) book called Yoga in Bed.
I know this could get confusing because brothels have come up a few times here, but it's for real, and was recommended to me by someone in the bookstore recently.
Once someone invents yoga in your sleep, I will be completely on board.
Has anyone here tried Zumba? It's a fast-paced dance workout where you have to perform Latin/hip-hop moves. I made a complete jackass of myself. Nobody with arthritis anywhere in their hips, legs, or backs should try it. Which is a bit of a shame, because a Zumba story from Adrian would be a joy forever, but his health is way more important than that.
Y' know...i cant really put it any other way...but fuck yoga...and this is through personal experience at the one next to that ginormous cathouse in st kilda.
i went once to stretch out some niggling back things and spent the next hour being yelled at to do the preying ibis, listening to people fart (and hearing that it was letting out negative energy (who was this charlatan??)) and came out and collapsed, literally...i was dangerously dehydrated according to a nurse friend who was picking me up..
anyway i have wavered...glad you saw the light...and good luck with that knee....they are just like back injuries...fucking annoying
Dan
Did you ever find any relief for your back?
Seana,
Evidently I'm not. I'd heard yoga was good for stress, but it just seemed to aggravate me more. I've since rediscovered running, which really does the trick. Not good for bad knees though so probably not a good idea for Adrian.
Anon
Never heard of it but it doesnt sound like my sort of thing.
Dan
Yup you must have gone to the same place I did. A real hell hole but surprisingly popular none the less.
I don't think most yoga teachers are drill sargeant types though. I always liked the pleasant Lilias of Lilias Yoga and You. And Richard Hittleman, who my Mom used to watch in deepest darkest childhood would never have dreamt of raising his voice--at least on television.
I was thinking senior yoga might be more my speed even when I was about 30, so I'm pretty sure there is some form that might suit any of us. Well, maybe not in Australia.
I've done a little bit of everything when it comes to exercise over the years, and I'd rather run wind sprints till I puke, lift big till I do serious nerve damage, or run a half-marathon, rather than sixty minutes of yoga.
For the inflexible, such as myself, yoga is pure hell.
-Brian O
Very funny piece. This would work well in a novel with one of your tough guy protagonists.
I had a terrible experience with Bikram yoga in Boston - the instructor did not understand the difference, really, between pushing oneself and doing injury to oneself. Baptiste yoga on the other hand was just the ticket for me and my blinding migraines. I don't know anything about BB but the instructors at his studios in Cambridge and Brookline were all learned in the ways of subtlety. I never was able to keep up with all of the exercises and I took water breaks all the time and I also lay face down on the mat from time to time when I needed a break - never an issue. I'd have gone more often but I couldn't afford it, and now I'm living in the hinterlands of Canada.
A few of my friends are pilates instructors - one of whom has a Denver Broncos player as a client. I don't know if he has knee issues though. One of the pilates instructors also has training here that might be of help to you:
http://www.egoscue.com/
It's an art, finding out what works for your body.
Says a friend who knows what there is to know about hot and other kinds of yoga and even teaches the stuff:
"Baron (Baptiste) is a little crazy, but that's what makes it fun. "
====================================
Detectives Beyond Borders
"Because Murder Is More Fun Away From Home"
http://www.detectivesbeyondborders.blogspot.com/
Bikram yoga has given me new life I found your blog to be greatly interesting,This is very nice blog I am waiting for your next blog post, Yoga is usually taught as a way to achieve physical and mental fitness .
Post a Comment