The ABC1 TV programme First Tuesday Book Club is having a vote to pick the "10 Australian books to read before you die". The titles that they have come up with so far make me think that Australia seems to punch a little under its weight in terms of literature. Unlike Brits (but like Americans) Aussies do not enjoy hearing criticisms of their country, even in such trivial spheres as culture and sport. Australia is a wonderful place, with friendly, open, tolerant people; it also has a fantastic overseas reputation and there is no nation in the world that hates Australia (even Kiwis are secret Aussiephiles judging from the number of them who emigrate here every year) but the bitter truth is that Australia has produced very few Earth shattering writers, mainly because, I think, Australians are too busy out enjoying themselves to sit in a dark room and produce great art.
...
When you look at some of the literature nominees over at the First Tuesday Book Club site you'll see what I'm talking about. Clive James's memoirs? The Slap? Bryce Courtenay? Tim Winton? Seriously is that the best you can do, Australia? I wonder how many people have actually read Picnic At Hanging Rock (including the bizarre final chapter?) Compare Australian literature to, say, oh, I don't know, Irish literature, an island that has a quarter of Australia's population and is a hundredth its size you'll see what I'm talking about. Who is the Australian James Joyce? Or Oscar Wilde? Or Samuel Beckett? Or George Bernard Shaw? Is Les Murray really in the same league as Seamus Heaney or WB Yeats? Where indeed is the Aussie Flann O'Brien or Sheridan or Sean O'Casey, Goldsmith or Swift? And if you think its only fair to talk about the twentieth century when Australia became a country, well in that time period Ireland has had 4 Nobel Prize winners in literature (not including Joyce), Australia has had 1. I don't want to go overboard with this; I do like Peter Carey (even though he went to uber snooty Geelong Grammar), Clive James, Eva Hornung, Alexis Wright and David Malouf, but my four favourite Australian books havent even made the ABC list so far. They are Monkey Grip by Helen Garner, about a divorced mother trying to make ends meet in a low rent Bohemian Melbourne; Tracks by Robyn Davidson, an almost unknown travel masterpiece; The Collected Poems of Peter Porter and The Lamb Enters The Dreaming by Robert Kenny, a history of the Christian missions to the Aboriginals in northern Victoria.
...
I'm not trying to upset my Australian friends with this post, as I pointed out Australia is a great place to live and raise a family, and I will say this for Australian literature, at least its better than Aussie pop music.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

30 comments:
Adrian,
Is Aussie pop so bad? I kind of liked the Church.
Hope to get my hands on the books mentioned in the last paragraph - they sound excellent.
You don't give a nod to Peter Temple?
I liked an intriguing series I read by B. Wongar on Aboriginal life I read some years ago, and I enjoyed the one novel I read of David Malouf's so far, although it on Ovid rather than Australia. And despite being disappointed in the last Peter Carey I read or half read, I have really enjoyed several of his books in the past.
And I loved Tim Winton's The Riders.
I don't buy this theory of having to sit in a dark room to write a good novel, but then I'm a Californian, so I wouldn't, would I?
As Seana said, plus.
Patrick White, of course.
Tim Winton's works are all outstanding. I reviewed his BREATH a while back, a parable involving surfing, sexual addiction, and autoerotic asphyxiation gone awry. His other works are often breath-taking as well.
Peter Temple's cross-genre thrillers THE BROKEN SHORE and TRUTH are also great.
Garry Disher's written some pretty good crime fiction "inspired" by Richard Stark, and other than that I can only think of Yasmine Gooneratne, the author of The Sweet and Simple Kind. She's actually from Sri Lanka, but has been an Aussie resident since 1972. She's presently an English prof at MacQuarie University in Sydney. You're missing an obvious job opening here, Adrian. Just change a few place names in your next book and hey, presto! you're immediately one of Oz's top authors. Come to think of it, why aren't you on the list? Do Aussie authors have to be born in Oz and write only about Oz? It's a land of immigrants so why not open the doors wide.
Can't contribute much as I have not read any AUS novels. Thanks for the one mentioned though. Hope to check out someday. Have seen a few good AUS movies though via On Demand.
Not sure if your still into Madmen, but I'm really digging this season. Roger's trip was a nice touch, especiallly when his cig shrinks.
Kate
Aussie pop is pretty bad. And certainly overrated by Australians many of whom still think INXS was a good band and that Kylie is some kind of talent.
The only thing worse than Australian pop is Australian country music which has an entire channel devoted to it in the 800's.
Seana
Peter Temple's a decent crime writer, but he's not an innovator like, say, Dashiell Hammett or James Ellroy.
I've never jumped on the Tim Winton bandwagon although he's ubiquitous over here.
Rich
I read a couple of Patrick Whites and found them fussy and a bit dry but ok.
Not the biggest Winton fan, but I'll go with you on Temple.
Cary
Well Peter Temple's South African really isn't he?
The Sweet and Simple Kind, eh? Dont know it. I'll have a look for it at the library today.
Sean
The recent episode threw me for a loop. I kept think how hot Julia Ormond was compared to her "daughter" Megan. I'm sure I should have been concentrating on the plot or something.
sad news about Adam Yauch of the Beastie Boys.
For me this was the high point:
sabotage
Randolph Stow is the only writer with an Australian background who ever meant anything to me. Someone I would have loved to have known.
You should get a new job. One you can do!!! LOL!!! LOL!!!
Samuel L. Jackson
What about Murray Bail or Kate Grenville? I take your point about though, comparing the Irish writers with just about anybody. But the Australians ARE great readers, so be happy, you are immersed in a place where people still do that despite the sports, the bush and the beach.
Mark
Dont know Stow. I shall look up.
Peter
that was Jackson's quote?
wow for those who believe in the transmutation of souls theres your proof, Oscar Wilde lives.
John
And a place with a terrific public library system. Dont forget that. At least Melbourne has anyway.
The Saints.
The Go Betweens.
The Laughing Clowns.
The Triffids.
The Birthday Party.
Crime and The City Solution.
Tasty bands, them.
What, you don't like Men at Work? (dating myself, I know). I like Adrian Hyland, Gary Disher and Peter Temple. These aren't Dashiell Hammett, but how many of those are there?
Paul
Any from the last five years?
Lil
Yup you do hear a lot of Men of Work in this country. And ACDC and Midnight Oil. In Australia its always 1982 in terms of music.
I do like Adrian Hyland, one of the few Australian crime writers who even acknowledges the vast land beyond the coast and the Aboriginals who live there.
Any from anywhere in the last 5 years? (Dons fogey cap.)
Paul
Hold on let me check my iPod...
Oh wait, yeah, I see what you mean. Fair point.
Adrian Hyland lived and worked among Aboriginal peoples in the Northern Territory for a long time. Maybe crime writers just have to get out more.
Adrian , I have to take issue with you on your aussie bands being uniformly crap assertion . Perth's " Sleepy Jackson" and in particular their frontman and songwriter Luke Steele are world class and Steele is a pop prodigy . Melbourne's Augie March are extremely literate and songwriters of the first order .I will agree with you that INXS were dross of the highest order and that Kylie is essentially talentless.She's the very definition of a marketeer's wet dream.
I have read a number of Peter Temple's books and have to say I enjoyed them all , they are all characterised by a black humour and have decent plots and sharp dialogue .As I usually gravitate towards crime novels I wouldn't feel qualified to comment on authors such as Peter Carey as this type of writer seems to be best considered by programmes such as the BBC 2 review show where 4 or 5 pompous "intellectuals" spend the best part of an hour telling us how clever they are !
Neil
I know The Sleep Jackson. From a family of prodigies, right? Yeah they're pretty good.
All pop music per se is pretty crappy these days...however delve into some other stuff and you will find a goldmine of current brilliance...f'rinstance:
Burn in Hell
Sideshow Brides
The UnAustralians
The Ears
Bittersweet Kicks
Kim Salmon
Spencer P Jones
For brevity I will not go on as I can list a bunch of great local stuff...however with all due respect may I take you to task on Oz country. Yes a lot of the commercially viable stuff is crap here and is a watered down version of Nashville trash, but look deeper and you will find some gold. May I suggest having a look at Clinton Walker's 'Buried Country'...a great look into Aboriginal country music...
Ok rave time is over ;)
Dan
thanks for the recs.
I'm especially intrigued by what you say about Oz Country, when I've gone to that channel its been pretty horrifying. Every Australian act seems to be a 62 year old dude with dyed hair wearing too tight denim singing off key bad Hank Williams knock offs to some embarrassed young blonde.
I'm 6 weeks away from graduating as a High School English and Drama teacher and trying to get up to speed with Australian literature and drama is making my eyes bleed.
Everything apart from Richard Flanagan seems to be about either a saturnine stockman or a housewife from Ballarat.
The less said about David Williamson plays, the better
Rob
I have a feeling that top 10 list is going to be pretty embarrassing. Especially if The Slap is number 1.
Post a Comment