from Saturday's Melbourne Age
The Hilliker Curse: My Pursuit of Women, by James Ellroy
During a 2006 book reading at the famous Skylight bookstore in East Hollywood, James Ellroy scanned the crowd of about two hundred fans and noted with satisfaction that about a third of them were women. After being introduced, he walked up to the lectern and addressed his audience: “Stop me now! It’s going to my head. I need a strong woman to tame me with her love and walk all over me in high, black boots.” After the reading seven women slipped him their phone numbers and he took three of them out to dinner.
...
The Hilliker Curse is full of stuff like this. It’s a funny and self depreciating memoir that uses the framing device of James Ellroy’s relationships women as a way of filling in his post teen life story. His previous memoir, My Dark Places, unpacked the horrific events surrounding his mother’s unsolved murder and his years as an adolescent neo Nazi and borderline sex pervert who got his kicks from stalking girls, breaking into their houses and sniffing their soiled underwear.
...
Well into his thirties he was haunted by the image of his sexually adventurous mother, Jean Hilliker, who he both loved and hated. (Shortly before she was murdered he told her that he wanted to live with his father and for that she slapped him so hard that it was still stinging fifty years later when he came to write about it.) Ellroy went to live with his wastrel father and became a junkie, alcoholic and ne’er do well who somehow felt that if only he could get his act together he would become a great artist like his idol, Beethoven. Beethoven, of course, was a product of the German Romantic movement and much of The Hilliker Curse feels like a Bildungsroman: the poverty stricken orphan struggles to make his way in the world and after many setbacks is triumphantly redeemed by the power of his pen.
...
In another writer this could get pretty precious but Ellroy is an autodidact who dodged Freud and is thus able to tell his story in a straightforward manner without a lot of psychobabble. For the uninitiated, however, he has made few compromises in his prose style: verbs are dispensed with, sentences clipped and he often writes in the breathless tones of a 1950's scandal sheet. Ellroy doesn’t “look” he “peeps” or “scopes.” He doesn’t “remember things” he “time travels”. This can get a little bit exhausting and it is perhaps symptomatic of a larger problem with The Hilliker Curse. Ellroy’s view of women is old fashioned and all together too reverential. He puts women on a pedestal and worships them and then condemns them for not living up to this image of perfection. I was reminded of a scene from Mad Men when Peggy upbraids her mentor Freddy Rumson for his talk of “broads” and “dames” and explains to him that women and times have changed. Ellroy’s Rat Pack language and attitudes were already becoming out of date in 1965. Not that Ellroy was ever too concerned about the counter culture. He hated hippies, kept his hair short, didn’t like girls who wore too much make up or nail polish. In his twenties and early thirties his main encounters with women seem to have been with prostitutes that he initially only wanted to “speak to” before succumbing to their other attractions. After producing such modern classics as LA Confidential and American Tabloid Ellroy appears to have hung out with an awful lot of adoring fans and you have to wonder whether hookers and groupies are the best pool from which to build a theory of the female gender or to find that elusive mother/lover for whom he was searching.
...
Interestingly I think Ellroy’s attitude towards women infects his fictional female characters too. I have never been completely convinced by any of them and they do not talk or act like any women I know, although, in his defense, no women I know are mixed up in plots to assassinate the President. Ellroy calls himself the “Tolstoy of crime fiction,” but you never really see him producing a character like Anna Karenina or Natalia Rostova. Then again, perhaps he was only kidding when he said that; he is one of America’s wittiest writers and The Hilliker Curse is full of hilarious scenes, many at his own expense. It is also scathingly honest and although it is not quite up there with My Dark Places it is certainly a worthy edition to the Ellroy canon and is recommended to both die hard fans and newbies alike.
Sunday, October 24, 2010
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
31 comments:
Glad to see a positive review, lately I've been reading reviews of the book that tore it apart.
It's a much better book than these negative reviews suggest, Ellroy actually is able to get to the core of his obsession, even tho putting the next WOMAN OF HIS LIFE on a piedestal all the time is kind of pathetic. But he'll never learn, of course.
The negative reviews whine about how he dissects his obsession with women and his mother AGAIN, but I mean... what do you expect? And he does it better then ever befora (MY DARK PLACES is a better book but it's more about his life and the investigation and less about the psychopatological obsession.)
Ferenc
All the negatives are true but for me the saving grace is that Ellroy is funny. If a reviewer misses that, he or she is missing a big part of the story. Ellroy is sending himself up and hamming it up for the cameras and often it's hilarious. It's usually never observed but he's actually one of America's wittiest writers.
He's one of America's great showmen and 1950s'-style stand-up comics, too. One probably ought to consider this in any Ellroy discussion.
======================
Detectives Beyond Borders
"Because Murder Is More Fun Away From Home"
http://www.detectivesbeyondborders.blogspot.com/
Peter
I laughed out loud half a dozen times during Hilliker which is more than I've laughed in any other book this year. Ellroy is Evelyn Waugh funny and if he were British he'd already be a national institution like Stephen Fry or someone.
That said his tics are becoming flaws. Great writers evolve, good writers stagnate.
I was talking about tics in Ellroy's schtick, not in his writing. You may remember that I heard him read from Blood is a Rover a little over a year ago and loved the show he put in. Since then, I've come to realize that he's been using some of the same lines for years about different books. But the oddest moment happened at the reading itself.
Like a wildman, he promised to answer "the rudest, the most invasive questions" from the audience. One guy asked him what was the most perverted, disgusting thing he had ever done, and what was the most money he had made in a year.
For the first, Ellroy fell back on a passage from the book that did not involve any character who was a plausible Ellroy surrogate. For the second, he said he had good years and bad years, depending on how much alimony he had to pay. How 1950s, white-guy, stand-up-comic is that? If he'd gone any further in that direction, he's have said, "the wife" or "the little woman."
Sorry about the Yankees. Of course, the Phillies might not be going anywhere after today, either.
======================
Detectives Beyond Borders
"Because Murder Is More Fun Away From Home"
http://www.detectivesbeyondborders.blogspot.com/
Peter
Oh I see what you're saying. Yes.
Thats a creepy question to ask Ellroy. Its not something to boast about or be proud of. I wonder how big a leap it is from the teenage to that Canadian airforce guy who broke into women's houses to sniff their underwear and who ended up murdering two of them:
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-11568074
The NYY have big structural problems. Do you really want to give defensively challenged (but iconic) players like Jeter and Posada four year contracts?
The question would have been creepier had Ellroy not virtually invited it. There was nothing creepy about the guy who asked it. He was just participating in the boisterous bravado that Ellroy initiated but pulled back from in the face of a tough question.
Are Jeter and Posada in the first years of four-year contracts?
By the way, I don't know if you've been following my Bouchercon posts, but my post-con hotel was half a block from where Miles Archer was shot. I also visited the building where the Whosis Kid was gunned down.
======================
Detectives Beyond Borders
"Because Murder Is More Fun Away From Home"
http://www.detectivesbeyondborders.blogspot.com/
Peter
I have been following, just dont have much to say because I'm kinda depressed that I'm not there.
Jeter, Posada and Pettite are all up for contract renewals
You may have talked me into this one. Ellroy fascinates me. I can't decide how much what he shows us is shtick, and how much is a deeply disturbed individual. I hated THE COLD SIX THOUSAND (in retrospect not the best Ellroy to start with), but loved BLOOD'S A ROVER. I've seen and read interviews where he's funny, charming, and a complete asshole, often in the same interview. My guess is he's probably all of the above, and one of the most fascinating people currently writing. I'd be happy to pay for his dinner for a chance to chat with him for a couple of hours, but I'd probably also want to have someone close by to come for me if necessary.
Dana
And yet he must also be extraordinarily disciplined to have produced so many books, which is an element that doesnt really come across in the interviews.
Funnily enough I'd flip Blood's A Rover and Cold 6000. I thought Cold was his masterpiece whereas I felt that Blood was a bit of a letdown after Cold and American Tabloid.
Which of us is right?
Me, obviously.
Kidding.
Didn’t Pettitte talk about retiring before this year? And I don’t mind saying that there were jokes in the newsroom last night about George Steinbrenner rising from the grave to fire Girardi.
======================
Detectives Beyond Borders
"Because Murder Is More Fun Away From Home"
http://www.detectivesbeyondborders.blogspot.com/
Peter
Not Girardi's fault at all. The NYY are just a very old team.
And Cashman is no genius.
Yes, Adrian, I was also thinking about Ellroy as the details of the air force guy started to come out. By the way, the interrogation of Williams (the air force guy) is really fascinating stuff. People are saying cop who conducted the interview was really impressive and pretty much all the evidence used to get the guilty plea came from the interview.
And I think you and Dana are both wrong, of course, American Tabloid is the best.
What is wrong with putting women on a pedestal, I ask you? It's when you start knocking them off it that you have a problem.
I don't know if writing is therapy or not, and I kind of hope it isn't, but I would guess the world is a little less creepy because Ellroy decided to write instead of peep for at least some of his waking hours.
I did meet him once briefly, and I liked him, though he was definitely 'on'. Seems like someone who would be hard to really know.
John
Gentle and continuous pressure seems to be the key in successful interrogations. No histrionics.
That first murder happened when the Colonel was disturbed breaking into a woman's house. Identified I suppose he felt he had nothing to lose. I wonder what would have happened if the teenage neo Nazi Ellroy had also been caught in flagrante.
I like American Tabloid a great deal but I still think Cold 6000 has a more sensational and exciting (and completely crazy) plot.
Seana
I've never met him or seen him, but that "on" description is disturbing. Makes him sound like - shudder - Robin Williams.
Spot on review,Adrian. I have met and
spoken with James a number of times since the late 1980's he is even more
over the top in private...his "black
humor" kinda reminds me of another
author from Carrickfergus(sp).
Paul
In the end its all about the writing isnt it?
If I ever wrote a book half as good as The Cold Six Thousand, believe me I'd die a happy man.
Have you all checked out Declan's interview with him over on CAP? Adrian's review and Declan's interview can be read profitably together.
I am going to change my opinion. Maybe he isn't always on. Maybe, because he never read Freud, he never learned that you are supposed to have a superego. Or he thought it meant a Super Ego.
I still like him though.
Seana
I meant to link to that, so thank you for doing so.
Very good Q&A as usual from Dec, although I noticed Dec didnt take James Ellroy out on the piss and then take a photograph of him at two in the morning with his camera phone.
Either he only reserves that for very special guests, or he is a bit more afraid of Ellroy than he is of you.
I haven't read Ellory yet, but I do have American Tabloid and The Black Dahlia sitting on my shelf waiting. I plan to get to them..hopefully sooner rather than later.
This was one of the books I bought for two long flights I just took. I finally managed to read it last night in the throes of jetlag and its irritating hours. I was a little disappointed.
As a book its fine but I found Ellroy to be playing up to the 'Demon Dog' character a bit much. I was lucky enough to have dinner with him about ten years ago and found him to be nothing like the character he plays at readings.
Rob, I've read Ellroy and seen and heard him, though I have not had dinner with him. I think you're right, though, that he plays a character at readings.
One forum in which he may both play that same character but also reveal a different side is the commentaries he does with Eddie Muller on some of the Film Noir Classics DVDs.
======================
Detectives Beyond Borders
"Because Murder Is More Fun Away From Home"
http://www.detectivesbeyondborders.blogspot.com/
Glenna
The Black Dahlia is more accessible but A.T. is the better book.
Rob
I guess he sees readings etc. as "showbiz" and thus comes to entertain, which is fair enough.
Peter
That is a little strange though isn't it? Assuming a stage persona for a book reading.
Why not? He's putting on a show. He seems to adopt that persona on television, too. Have you listened to any of his film noir commentaries with Eddie Muller? Ellroy alternates among his usual schtick, nostalgia for old California sites, and a deep appreciation of film technique. The commentaries are well worth a listen. Muller is superb.
======================
Detectives Beyond Borders
"Because Murder Is More Fun Away From Home"
http://www.detectivesbeyondborders.blogspot.com/
The persona for readings is fine but I found it difficult when he appeared to be using it in the latest book.
Anyhow, the point is that he seems to adopt the schticky persona for public occasions, not just readings. The film commentaries are semi-public and semi-schtick. (He did mention the new love of his life more than once during the reading I attended.)
Have to hope he turns the schtick off for her. At least sometimes.
Post a Comment