Monday, November 28, 2011

Moneyball

Nope not even Brad Pitt can pull off the AARP Visor look
The film Moneyball is the true-ish story of Billy Bean, the general manager of the Oakland A's and his conversion to the Bill James school of baseball statistics. Bill James has long held that getting on base is the most important thing a player can do and it doesn't matter how he does it. Ruth and Bonds to name but two were just as valuable for their walks as their hits. Moneyball takes us back to the 2002 season when Oakland lost Jason Giambi to the Yankees and Johnny Damon to the Red Sox. To replace these stars Bean (Brad Pitt) and a statistician played by Jonah Hill decide to ignore their scouts and dive into the Bill James world. The film follows the sacred arc of baseball movies: 1) a bunch of misfits is assembled by a general manager who wants to give them all a second chance 2) they dont gel and initially they lose a lot of games 3) the manager/general manager yells at them 4) they start to turn the season around 5) they win a lot of games 6) there is a climactic final game which they win (The Natural, Major League) or lose (Eight Men Out, The Bad News Bears). 
...
Despite strictly following this sacred arc or iron law of baseball films I really enjoyed Moneyball. Brad Pitt has decided to age like Robert Redford, that is, rapidly and all at once but its added character to his face and as in The Tree Of Life he turns in a first rate, thoughtful performance here. Jonah Hill is great as the soft spoken geek, Philip Seymour Hoffman is his usual fantastic self, Kerris Dorsey the girl playing Pitt's daughter, is charming and does a nice job with the song over the end credits. Spike Joynze shows up in a funny cameo as Robin Wright's new husband and as a little nod to Bull Durham they even cast Arliss Howard as John Henry at the end. 
...
Fine acting, a tight script, both Giambi brothers as villains, lots of baseball, what more do you want in a movie? 

16 comments:

speedskater42k said...

I liked the book and think Michael Lewis a very worthwhile non-fiction author.

I've not seen the movie, but would expect to be disappointed.

adrian mckinty said...

Speedskater

I think thats a good philosophy for life.

Kate said...

Philip Seymour Hoffman is always good. He was good in Spike Lee's The Eleventh Hour, and he and Laura Linney were great as a brother and sister in a movie called Savages. People underestimate Brad Pitt; he was really good in Babel.

adrian mckinty said...

Kate

Philip Seymour Hoffman elevates everything he's in, except maybe The Big Lebowski which couldnt really be elevated anymore than it is.

It must suck to be Brad Pitt getting underestimated like that all the time.

seana said...

I think I'd like this one. Even though I don't really enjoy sports, I like movies about sports. Kind of like how I don't really like wearing jewelry, but for some reason I like watching jewelry television.

I was impressed by that short article that Lewis did on Ireland. He's a good, lucid writer.

adrian mckinty said...

Seana

I havent read Moneyball but I might after watching the film. I was under the impression that there would be lots of Yankee bashing but there wasn't.

I just listened to Mark Kermode's review on BBC Radio 5 and he said it liked because there was so little sports actually in it.

seana said...

It's funny, but I don't mind actually watching sports in movies either. I get the contest and the suspense of it all.

In real life, though, I have some problems with the intensity that comes with fandom.

Peter Rozovsky said...

I saw a trailer, and I thought having Billy Bean's stats-obsessed-sidekick look like such a typical high school nerd did not bode well. On the other hand, Tony La Russa did not like the movie, which does bode well.

Matt said...

Don't give me any of your honkey BS, McKinty!

lil Gluckstern said...

As a San Francisco Giants fan, I'm supposed to hate the A's, but I don't. Brad Pitt is Just a pretty face, but he isn't. Nor has he been for a long time. Besides, baseball managing has become such an arcane practice, that this movie sounds really interesting. I will see it.

adrian mckinty said...

Seana

Fear of intensity may be your Scottish heritage.

adrian mckinty said...

Peter

Yeah I read that. He felt that the scouts had be dissed a bit which in the movie they were.

adrian mckinty said...

Matt

Moneyball is such a peculiar film that even David Justice gets to play the hero.

adrian mckinty said...

Lil

The science only seems arcane but actually its pretty simple. OBP (on base percentage) is king.

seana said...

Maybe, but I think it has more to do with my aversion to team spirit.

DJD said...

Good movie. It sort of mirrors baseball, as there is not a ton of action. When it comes, it is meaningful, but it's not really what the movie is about. It's about strategy (again - like baseball) and believing in a new and different way of doing things. Brad Pitt's acting was convincing and the story had a not fast but not too sluggish pace. Good flick overall - I thought.