Thursday, December 8, 2011

The Cynical Hearts of Wieden and Kennedy




I remember the moment when I decided that I was never going to buy another pair of Levis Jeans. It was not, as you would expect, a midlife crisis style epiphany when I suddenly realised that I wasn't a kid anymore but a man who should be wearing cords or slacks or whatever it is that men wear. No, it was nothing like that, it was when I saw Levi's 'America' ad which had a series of images celebrating America over a scratchy recording of Walt Whitman reading his poem America that also, er, celebrates America. What got me upset was the hypocrisy of this because the ad came only a year or two after Levis closed down its last plant making jeans in America. That's the play isn't it? Move your stitching factories to sweatshops overseas, hike the prices and then hire a cool ad agency whose job it is to fool the public into thinking that nothing has changed. Wrangler, that sponsor of rodeos and bull riding and stock car races, also makes none of its jeans in America. But these great companies do.
...
The Levis ad was made by Wieden and Kennedy who are also responsible for the Microsoft Ads and the Nike commercials among many others. (Mr Wieden came up with the "just do it" tag line which is enough cultural vandalism for one lifetime.) The Levis America ad is part of a new campaign for Levis called Go Forth which targets young wannabe individuals. I saw the latest commercial in this campaign in the cinema before The Ides of March (above, right). This ad has already generated some controversy. It was banned in the UK following last August's riots and nutcase/political commentator Glenn Beck saw it and said he wants to boycott Levis in protest because it will cause youth rebellion or something. The ad is a reading - by a Native American actor - of the Charles Bukowski poem The Laughing Heart. I can't believe that Bukowski would have been happy to see his poem used in this context and the idea that somehow the meaning of life can be enhanced or discovered through a pair of trousers made in a third world sweat shop surely doesn't convince even the naivest of the Millennium generation, does it?
...
In the second youtube clip I've uploaded Adam Curtis explains where some of this cynical advertising stuff came from on the Jarvis Cocker Radio show.

20 comments:

John McFetridge said...

Adrian, have you read Jonathan Dee's novel, Palladium? It's set mostly in an advertising agency.

seana said...

I couldn't actually get those video links to work, but they were fairly easy to look up.

On the ad, one thing that struck me was how bleak the setting is. It's a long way from Coke's I'd Like to Teach the World to Sing spot. It's more like, the ship is going down fast, but maybe we can salvage a remnant of something.

I liked the piece with Adam Curtis. I also liked the first segment of All Watched Over--didn't connect that I hadn't watched the second segment already via this blog until the end. Still have the third to go.

More determined than ever not to go on Facebook, although the blog world is really just the same thing writ small.

When I linked to the interview via YouTube I was sure I knew which person was Cocker and which was Curtis. I was completely wrong.

I strongly object to the California effect or whatever it was. California isn't one thing.It is a lot of things.

I also think Bill Clinton, who I don't actually like very much, was a lot more savvy than Curtis portrays him to be.

I liked the bit about Carmen Hermosillo. She was right. The triumph of the corporation is that it has persuaded us to provide content for free.

adrian mckinty said...

John

I havent read that and I havent read that famous Ogilvey book either but I'd like to.

adrian mckinty said...

Seana

I find myself in agreement with Carmen Hermosillo. We're providing all this free content for Google, corporatising our lives, emotions etc. for what exactly?

I've become more and more sympathetic to those alleged nuts who just live off the grid in New Mexico or Arizona with solar panels on their roof and no TV or cable or internet.

Anonymous said...

Adrian,

Thanks for the American Made directory, and for the introduction to Tom Waits and Charles Bukowski.
The Levis ad was disturbing. Its makers were clearly educated and intelligent (and ass men, judging from the abundance of butt shots - oh, well). A waste of creativity. You were never tempted to try advertising, were you?

Girish Shahane said...

Adrian,
'Chinese factory' seems to be a synonym for 'sweatshop' these days. However, I believe a number of them aren't sweaty at all.
Which isn't to say the ad isn't hypocritical.
Girish

adrian mckinty said...

Anon

Advertising aint my thing and I dont think I have the talent anyway.

I'll be getting my jeans from American Apparel from now on.

adrian mckinty said...

Girish


When the Chinese sweatshops arent sweaty enough no doubt they'll be moved to somewhere even cheaper. I think this is already happening as the Chinese economy starts to inflate.

adrian mckinty said...

And speaking of living off the grid. I saw this apocalypse proof house in the Daily Mail:

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2072486/For-hard-evil-genius-looking-lairs--18m-Cold-War-missile-silo-underground-bunker-sale-just-1-76m.html

Frankie said...

The voice-over in the Levis ad is a bit like Baz Luhrmann's Sunscreen isn't it?

Your right not to reward these companies and ad agencies with your money,its the only way. Nothing is made in the country it should be made in now. How you feel about Levis is how I feel about Cadbury's being bought by American Kraft foods and moved to Poland to make. I gave up chocolate in protest, but I am only human,I lasted only a week.

seana said...

They wait till the very end of the article to tell you that you can buy property there with access to the silo for only $750,000! That's what a nice but not extraordinary house in Santa Cruz would cost even after the slump and there is no silo included!

Or, at least, advertised.

I ride the bus sometimes with people who live pretty off the grid up in the mountains, and I am not convinced it's the best idea for sanity.

Eamonn Crowley said...

I had a similar response to bottled water after watching F.L.O.W. and tapped on Netflix last summer. The night before I stopped and bought a bottle en route to the gym. After seeing the screwjob Nestle et al put on communities all around the world I haven't bought one since and nobody in my 8 person immediate family has either. I think it's these epipjanies that keep us engaged in spite of the available corporatization and commodification of every facet of our lives. To answer as MacDuff with an absolute sir, not I can be very invigorating. Levis never fit me right anyway.

Rastamick61 said...

Gave credit to my son's account, a good lad all the same and he's been listening to Dead yard at bedtime every night this week !

Peter Rozovsky said...

Adrian, this post makes me want to take my pants off this second in protest, but it's pretty cold up here. (Sadly, I am no longer in Portugal.) I have saved your list, though.

I remember driving across North America many years ago and sneering at the "Buy American" bumper stickers in the Midwest. As Phil Ochs once almost sang, I ain't sneering anymore.
======================
Detectives Beyond Borders
"Because Murder Is More Fun Away From Home"
http://www.detectivesbeyondborders.blogspot.com/

adrian mckinty said...

Frankie

In Australia, NZ and SE Asia the Cadburys comes from a factory in Tasmania. It does NOT taste the same at all.

adrian mckinty said...

Seana

Yup sanity, hygiene etc. are just the part of the price that you have to pay I guess.

adrian mckinty said...

Eamonn

And speaking of chocolate and Nestle. Nestle bought out Rowntrees and everything was fine for a few years before they moved the production of Smarties overseas.

Rowntree was a Quaker who provided free schools, libraries etc. for his workers. I somehow dont see Nestle doing that, but maybe I'm wrong.

adrian mckinty said...

Rastamick

Hopefully by the end of the week he'll be a top swearer.

adrian mckinty said...

Peter

Its fine to move your jeans plant overseas if you want, but then you should be forced to use the iconography of the country you move it to. If the jeans come from Malaysia then have ads proudly proclaiming the achievements and imagery of Malaysia. Similarly with the Phillipines, Guatemala etc.

Frankie said...

I agree with your last comment, but I would go further. Exile the unpatriotic traitors to their preferred country of manafacture.